Re: Worst review of all time?

"Walter Mitty" <mitticus@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:slrndr5bao.an6.mitticus@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
>I was recently looking into buying a resonably priced RPG : I came
> across this review of Gothic 2.
>
> http://www.rpgamer.com/games/gothic/gothic2/reviews/goth2strev1.html
>
> Quite possibly the most poorly writte, inconcistent review of any SW
> product I have ever read.
>
> See if you can see why.
>
> (And I dont mean the 5/5 score).

The fact this guy dings a game because he only has 256MB of memory despite
teh fact that the game recommends 512MB? I suppose I can sort of see his
issue given that 256MB is the minimum requirement, but if he has played any
games at all over the last ten years he should know you will never get
optimum performance with the minimum specs. And why he gave it 5/5 when he
calls the issue a "tragic flaw" is pretty inexplicable.

Personally, I enjoy Gothic 2 but have yet to finish it. I'll have to remedy
that.

turk
--
"I think we are welcomed. But it was not a peaceful welcome." -George W.
Bush, defending Vice President *** Cheney's pre-war assertion that the
United States would be welcomed in Iraq as liberators, NBC Nightly News
interview, Dec. 12, 2005


.

Quantcast