Re: give the example of the ..



On Fri, 29 Jul 2005, Phlip wrote:

> Cadence wrote:
>
> > I dont think in my years of software testing, I have ever had a bug that
> > was:
> > Low Priority High severity
> >
> > If it's severe enough, its fricken high priority.
>
> I'm your boss. Please fix the bugs I marked "high priority" first, not that
> bug.
>
> I know the circumstances and severity of every bug you report. Thank you for
> giving me enough information to do my job.
>
> My job to track our business needs, and to appease our customers. If the
> high-severity bug bites us while you the things I told you to, I take full
> responsibility.
>
> Otherwise, it's your responsibility.
>
> (Put another way, "high priority" means something different than "really
> extra high severity".)

This reminds me of one company I worked at. They didn't use Priority and
Severity. They just marked bugs as Priority. P1 was had to be fixed
because it affects other people on the project. P2 was had to be fixed
before we ship because it would annoy the customer and we know we can fix
it without impacting the release date. P3 was really should be fixed but
we can tell the customer how to avoid it; fixing it would delay the
product release. They were very focused on release dates. They would ship
defects that would cause total data loss setting the customer back weeks.
They would just tell the customer the steps to reproduce the defect and to
be sure not to do that. One of many reasons I don't work there anymore.

--
Send e-mail to: darrell dot grainger at utoronto dot ca

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: high severity-low priority
    ... Here is how I see the debate of severity and priority -- ... When the developers have plenty of time, bug arrival rate is lagging ... can be modified by test lead if there is real need. ...
    (comp.software.testing)
  • Re: give the example of the ..
    ... > Having seen "low severity" bugs (let through in order to meet the ... > you that engineers don't assign severity very often. ... You describe priority. ... > you get your self the priority of the bug. ...
    (comp.software.testing)
  • Re: high severity-low priority
    ... >Severity is how much it will affect the customer, ... and ultimately it's risk to the business. ... priority is a ranking of the order in which the bug will be ...
    (comp.software.testing)
  • Re: give the example of the ..
    ... > I dont think in my years of software testing, I have ever had a bug that ... its fricken high priority. ... I know the circumstances and severity of every bug you report. ... Otherwise, it's your responsibility. ...
    (comp.software.testing)
  • Re: give the example of the ..
    ... > High Priority low severity ... > High Priority High severity ... Schedule this bug to be removed immediately. ...
    (comp.software.testing)