Re: [9fans] sad commentary

this blog-style opinion piece does not offer anything constructive.
for example, would utf-8 qualify as a functionality that didn't exist
before plan9?

The fact the UTF-8 was first "implemented" on Plan 9 has nothing to do with Plan 9's funtionality as an OS. Similarly, the fact that Windows is "still" the best platform if you need to do word processing in many languages has nothing to do with its comparatively low performance with many applications--an important OS functionality it lacks.

FreeBSD's very good process scheduling, which manifests to a user like me in not having to worry about a non-responsive system in case a process is poorly performing, "is" an OS funtionality.

If the availability of UTF-8 is an advantage, the absence of a single Unicode font in the system useful for non-Latin languages is a very strong disadvantage. UTF-8 in an English-only "user" paradigm is only extravagance. I even doubt there's a "simple" way of inputting, say, Hebrew or Arabic in Plan 9. It'll be kind of you to clarify that point for me if I'm mistaken.

what's sad is that unless there's a dummy's guide to
something, that something is not considered a success.

The question is what new function Plan 9, as an OS, defines for the end user. Does it enable me of doing something Windows doesn't? Does it enable me of doing something better than I could do on FreeBSD? Does its default GUI even match Windows in ease of use (read: switching to another window, killing the window you're running, doing a simple copy without typing in regexps/wildcards, et cetera)?

By the way, I provided a description of my person to avoid "dummy" labels. I may well be a "dummy" in your league but that doesn't mean I'm unable of reading a normal technical manual. I can do and have done that, on Linux, FreeBSD, and Plan 9.

And success, by definition, doesn't need an apology. When there's an apology there must have been a measure of failure.

Best wishes,
Eris Discordia

--On Monday, June 30, 2008 1:42 PM -0700 Skip Tavakkolian <9nut@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Plan 9 neither fulfills
previous functions nor defines new ones for any "end user" or even
"hobbyist," except perhaps the most sturdy of them.

this blog-style opinion piece does not offer anything constructive.
for example, would utf-8 qualify as a functionality that didn't exist
before plan9?

there are many plan9 ideas that have been adopted by other os --
though the results often are Frankenstein-esque.

Eris Discordia

P.S. Heck, this "is" some sad commentary.

what's sad is that unless there's a dummy's guide to
something, that something is not considered a success.

-Skip







.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Difference between .NET and Java
    ... > people that I know agree with my speculation that the CLR was in fact ... > similarities between the CLR and the Win32 API. ... Actually what I ment to say was the .NET has Windows specific functionality ...
    (comp.lang.java.programmer)
  • Re: very slow computer
    ... Enquire, plan and execute ... Running windows xp home. ... Minimising the use of Add-Ons with Internet Explorer will help. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.help_and_support)
  • Re: microsoft download site indicates that my version is not authentic
    ... > packs is increasing functionality, which is wrong as much as it is a fix. ... I assume you have actually used a previous version of Windows? ... >>> You should as lost revenue means less to spend on the Billions of dollars>> each year it costs us to develop Windows and other products for you. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)
  • Re: Asking Windows Specific Questions
    ... This may not be windows specific, ... interacts which interacts with a windows program called winamp (A music ... I would need would be to invoke winamp if it is not already running. ... Provide uninstall functionality ...
    (comp.lang.java.programmer)
  • Re: Windows XP keeps restarting
    ... Enquire, plan and execute ... Is any version of Windows Server installed? ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.help_and_support)
Loading