Re: parts of speech in Ruby
- From: "Todd Benson" <caduceass@xxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Tue, 9 Oct 2007 11:28:08 +0900
On 10/8/07, Morton Goldberg <m_goldberg@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
On Oct 8, 2007, at 5:44 PM, Chad Perrin wrote:
I'm curious -- exactly what class of syntactic element is `=` in Ruby,
where "class of syntactic element" is roughly analogous to "part of
speech". If objects are nouns and methods are verbs, that means
`=` is
neither a noun nor a verb. Is it a participle? Is it
punctuation? If
it's a participle, I'd like to know what class of syntactic element
that
is in Ruby. If it's punctuation, I'd like some explanation for how
that
works conceptually -- because I think of punctuation in Ruby as being
stuff like the parentheses around a method argument.
Anyone? Bueller?
I think it might be consider a copula. See <http://en.wikipedia.org/
wiki/Copula>.
Regards, Morton
I agree with Morton a little here, since "a = b" doesn't necessarily
mean "a is b".
I suppose it's all about how far you want to take it conceptually.
Like, for example, in my head I see "a = b" as "a tries to put on b's
shoes", or to make it more short, something like, "b marries a".
In another language, that might sound more like "b, a, they become
together for a while".
For all simplicity, though, I guess the copula term could best
describe it for the English language.
Not a straight answer, but, there you go.
class C
def []= something
puts "hello"
end
end
b = C.new[] = "hola"
The semantics break down when you look at a single symbol (in this
case, '=') and try to replace it with a word (be it verb, transitive,
cupola or otherwise).
I don't know your use case, but I think it's impossible to translate a
programming language into a spoken one. I would be fascinated if you
could prove me wrong though.
Todd
.
- References:
- parts of speech in Ruby
- From: Chad Perrin
- Re: parts of speech in Ruby
- From: Morton Goldberg
- parts of speech in Ruby
- Prev by Date: Re: Ruby and RoR book recommendations
- Next by Date: Re: Itinerary for a Traveling Salesman (#142)
- Previous by thread: Re: parts of speech in Ruby
- Next by thread: Re: parts of speech in Ruby
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|
