Re: Choosing a place to publish
- From: Kaba <none@xxxxxxxx>
- Date: Wed, 5 Aug 2009 22:55:56 +0300
Nicolas Bonneel wrote:
For computer graphics in general, journals are not better than
conferences (at least because journals can take years to publish an
article which has been accepted, and computer graphics and hardware
evolve too fast so that it's tolerable). In practice, some conferences
in graphics are associated with journals, in special issues, so the best
thing to do if you want a journal paper is to submit to such conferences
(which are fast to publish).
I am not familiar with the correct terms yet. For all the papers that
I've been involved with, someone else has chosen the publication place.
So hmm.. A journal is a collection of papers that is published at
regular intervals, for example 4 times a year or so, right?
A conference would be a place where the accepted and peer-reviewed
papers are represented to an audience and then maybe (or always?)
compiled to conference proceedings?
What else is there to terminology?
Except if you highly motivate your kd-tree research for graphics, there
is little hope that it will be accepted in these conferences (which are
very graphics oriented). However, if you motivate it by showing some CG
applications, then it may be fine.
Just recall that Siggraph and Siggraph Asia have about 15% acceptance
rate, and that there is also a self selection (you usually don't submit
if you're sure to be rejected)... so don't hope too much. There is also
a part of randomness at the end.
I can be more specific. I have something about point containing kd-trees
especially in connection with nearest neighbors searching (but not
restricted to). I agree that it doesn't seem to fit any of those
mentioned, for example, in Kesen Huang's nice webpage you linked to. In
short, it's not a graphics related journal that I should be searching
for.
But who is it then? Computational geometry? Pattern recognition? Hmm..
Let's see where some of the previous nearest neighbors papers have been
published (snippets from the middle of the name):
.... symposium on discrete algorithms ...
.... transaction of mathematical software ...
.... data compression ...
.... computational geometry ...
.... Algorithmica ...
Discreet & computational geometry
These names are from quite old papers. The computational geometry is the
only that clearly comes out. Maybe that's where I should look.
--
http://kaba.hilvi.org
.
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: Choosing a place to publish
- From: Nicolas Bonneel
- Re: Choosing a place to publish
- References:
- Choosing a place to publish
- From: Kaba
- Re: Choosing a place to publish
- From: Nicolas Bonneel
- Choosing a place to publish
- Prev by Date: Re: Choosing a place to publish
- Next by Date: Re: building a 3d model
- Previous by thread: Re: Choosing a place to publish
- Next by thread: Re: Choosing a place to publish
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|
Loading
