Re: about min max filters?

On Dec 19, 10:16 pm, "Fred Marshall" <fmarshallx@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
wrote:
dbd wrote:
...

Yes, but that task does not determine the frequency response of an LTI
filter but of a filter and particular data set.

Actually it does if you are willing to define a single filter based on a
single data set. Then, that one filter can be analyzed for arbitrary data.
The fact that you don't *intend* to apply that one filter to but one data
set is something you decide to do with it - but has nothing to do with your
ability to analyze the filter.

In a way, this is a "partitioning" of the question.

Now, I know that this perspective may deviate from the mathematical
expression that resulted in the filter in the first place. That is likely a
sticking point.


The sticking point is that the filter is not LTI so the analysis does
not give the properties of an LTI filter and one can't make the usual
assumptions that go along with linear time invariance.

This is not a strong argument. Just an observation. The observation leads
to an ability to analyze families of LTI filters that could lead to useful
insight - and that part is data / application dependent as Tim mentioned.

That is not a strong argument. Just an observation in error when
claiming a provide to linear time invariant analysis. Analysis with
relevant data sets may be worthwhile, just not LTI in this case.


Fred

Dale B. Dalrymple
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Sinc Interpolation
    ... > I have a data set obtained by combining elements from 3 different ... > How can I interpolate my data sample using Sinc function? ... use a sinc that has zero spacing of 10 ... with a FIR filter. ...
    (comp.dsp)
  • Re: about min max filters?
    ... filter but of a filter and particular data set. ... Actually it does if you are willing to define a single filter based on a ... not give the properties of an LTI filter and one can't make the usual ...
    (comp.dsp)
  • Re: notch filter, sinusoidal vs. non-sinusoidal
    ... wants to remove daily fluctutations from it. ... DFT the whole data set and set the relevant bins to 0. ... What this filter does, is that it puts a zero exatly on the unit circle ... The notch is put on the nominal location of the interfering line ...
    (comp.soft-sys.matlab)
  • Re: Advance Filter & If Code
    ... My data set is located in column U:V only, ... when user chose a value in the drop down control, the advance filter will ... Dim WS1 As Worksheet ...
    (microsoft.public.excel.programming)
  • Re: about min max filters?
    ... filter but of a filter and particular data set. ... Actually it does if you are willing to define a single filter based on a ... not give the properties of an LTI filter and one can't make the usual ...
    (comp.dsp)