FCC Should be Required to More Accurately Count Broadband Users

Senator Decides Maybe The FCC Should Be Required To More Accurately
Count Broadband Users (From the what-a-concept dept)

For years and years, plenty of people (including the Government
Accountability Office) have been pointing out why the FCC's numbers on
broadband penetration are wildly misleading. Remember, they simply count
by zip code. That is, if a single house has connectivity from a single
provider in that zip code, the FCC says that provider can reach every
house in that zip code. That's obviously not true at all. Yet the FCC
keeps using that data, no matter how many times they're told its wrong.
Now, Senator Daniel Inouye is proposing new rules that would require the
FCC count things a bit more accurately.

First, it would ask the GAO to come up with its own metrics that don't
just look at "broadband" but also consider cost and capability in
determining what's really available. Then, it would look to redefine
broadband based on different speed levels, rather than just consider
anything over 200k as broadband. Finally, it would push for
classifications based not on the 5 digit zip code, but the 9 digit zip
codes which further segment regions. It would certainly be a step in
the right direction, though still not perfect.

Meanwhile, the group The Information Technology and Innovation
Foundation has put out its own recommendations that sound quite
similar to the Senator's, with one addition: setting up a
user-generated mapping tool. The idea would be to set up a broadband
speed test offer (similar to what Broadband Reports offers today), and
then use location information to get a pretty detailed picture of what
kinds of broadband speeds are available where. This seems like such a
sensible approach to the issue that we're almost positive it'll never
be implemented.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Internet Speeds Are Often Slower Than What Consumers Pay For, FCC Finds
    ... Internet Speeds Are Often Slower Than What Consumers Pay For, FCC ... The small army at the FCC trying to figure out how to bring broadband ...
    (sci.military.naval)
  • Re: Slow broadband..
    ... "FCC Finds Slow Broadband Speeds" ... advertising practice. ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • BPL as posted about a day or so ago
    ... to make sure that BPL DOES NOT INTERFERE WITH EXISTING SERVICES. ... maybe the FCC isn't the greatest thing next to God or plug in your own ... FCC ADOPTS MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER ON BROADBAND OVER POWER LINES ... its rules for Access Broadband Over Power Lines Systems ...
    (rec.radio.scanner)
  • FCC Issues Rule Allowing FBI to Dictate Wiretap-Friendly Design for Internet Service
    ... "Tech Mandates Force Companies to Build Backdoors into Broadband, ... DC - Today the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) ... Communications Assistance to Law Enforcement Act (CALEA). ...
    (alt.computer.security)
  • Re: BPL draws more media attention ...
    ... The following from the ARRL Letter of Nov 9, ... "FCC Releases Broadband Report: The FCC has released their latest ... report summarizing the state of broadband in the US as of December ...
    (rec.radio.amateur.antenna)