Re: Multicast in hsrp scenario



Multicast traffic doesn't use HSRP. IP Multicast is just a way to do layer
2 multicast over a layer 3 network. A default gateway is only used to
figure out the layer 2 address of the next hop gateway. If you look at a
unicast packet the destination IP is the destination IP address of the
packet and the layer 2 address is the MAC address on the next layer 2 hop,
which is the MAC address of the router. A multicast packet has the
destination IP of the IP multicast group that the packet belongs to, which
is computed from the layer 2 multicast address, which NEVER changes. So in
your scenario, even if rB is the active HSRP router, rA is going to be
forwarding the multicast traffic.

Scott

<Bod43@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1175106248.418850.21850@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Picture designed for monospace type. e.g. courier.

---------- --------
| sw1 |------| pc1 Tx |
---------- --------
/ \
/ \
/ \
/ \
/ \
/ \
/ \
E0 / \ E0
---------- X ----------
| rA |-------------| rB |
---------- ----------
|
|
|
--------
| pc2 Rx |
--------




Multicast query.

We have 2 routers A, B with routed links between them.
A switch (with a single VLAN) connects routers A, B.

rA port E0 and rB port E0 and all the switch ports
are on the same broadcast domain, all
other links are point to point routed links. All router ports are
configured for PIM sparse mode.

We are running (say) OSPF and all links are the same cost.

pc2 registers for some multicast group with IGMP and
pc1 sends frames to that group.

The issue that I am trying to understand is that as far as I can see
the multicast may or may not work depending on the PIM designated
router selected. This will be either rA-E0 or rB-E0.

In the event that rB-E0 is the designated router the multicast
frames will be forwarded by rB and not by rA.
When these frames reach port X they will fail the RPF test and
be dropped.

Is this an invalid configuration for multicast operation?

Guess I must have the wrong end of some stick or other.

Thanks.



.



Relevant Pages

  • Multicast in hsrp scenario
    ... Multicast query. ... B with routed links between them. ... rA port E0 and rB port E0 and all the switch ports ... All router ports are ...
    (comp.dcom.sys.cisco)
  • Re: Cisco EIGRP "Hello"
    ... always having destination as my multicast. ... >seeing this on a machine that only has very specific tcp/udp rules per ... >port, with IPTables default policy for all being DROP, and only about 15 ... >flooding ethereal's logs with the router set to allow multicast to pass ...
    (comp.security.firewalls)
  • Re: Maximum MAC multicast filters? --clarified--
    ... > I want to subscribe to lots of layer 3 multicast groups. ... many NICs use an imperfect hash to filter ...
    (comp.dcom.lans.ethernet)
  • Re: Maximum MAC multicast filters? --clarified--
    ... >> There are 2^23 MAC layer multicast addresses. ... I want to subscribe to lots of layer 3 multicast groups. ...
    (comp.dcom.lans.ethernet)
  • Re: LAN, Switching and Routing: Multicast advice needed on Cat 6513 IOS 12.2SXF5
    ... routing) and another context for layer 2 (multicast switching) ... IGMP is enabled by default for layer 2, and is enabled for layer 3 by ... IGMP messages are "snooped" passively by the switch to determine ...
    (comp.dcom.sys.cisco)