Re: What is the logic of storing XML in a Database?

On 2007-03-28, Cimode <cimode@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

What advantage of XML as a transport format do you see over let's say
a CSV file with an integrated header?

There's nothing that you can do with XML that can't be done in other ways.
But of course there's very little that you can do with a computer that you
can't eventually do with pencil and paper. Not all of the advantages of XML
are immediately obvious.

From my experience of replacing legacy formats with XML the main benefits
are:

Data can be validated before it's transmitted. Validation against a schema
will trap most major errors. It will trap most of the minor errors that
would normally require action by an expensive and extremely bored human being.
Therefore it reduces processing costs and staff turnover.

Errors are rejected by a machine. That usually makes it the sender's
responsibility to check and correct the data. Making that unambiguous saves
a lot of time and endless arguments between business partners.

Code to handle XML is standardised and therefore doesn't need to be
rewritten for each individual application. This makes it more reliable and
cheaper to develop and maintain.

It is difficult to extend CSV systems boyond the simple flat-file system
with a single record type. Traditionally, at least in the systems I've
worked with, the solution is to denormalise the data from more than one
table. Therefore CSV is usually more verbose than XML and can take up much
more storage space. (The storage space argument isn't one I usually have a
lot of time for - it's not usually worth bothering with.)

XML data is not generally manually edited, this is a huge advantage. Fixing
manually prepared data files soaks up vast amounts of time and effort. It's
more likely that XML files will be generated and read by automated systems
than by someone typing data. That makes XML data much more reliable than
CSV.


--
bap@xxxxxxxxxx
In search of cognoscenti
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: What is the logic of storing XML in a Database?
    ... can't do with CSV. ... In what a header does constitute a schema. ... So a schema is the standard structure by which the user sending a file ... in much the same way that XML standards are. ...
    (comp.databases.theory)
  • Re: ultra newbie question (dont laugh)
    ... storing employee information in an XML file. ... but not as fun as writing the logic. ... On reason to use OOP is to insulate your main code from things like storage ... from CSV file. ...
    (comp.lang.python)
  • Re: What is the logic of storing XML in a Database?
    ... will trap most major errors. ... In fact one does, XML. ... CSV is useful for unloading an SQL table into a text ...
    (comp.databases.theory)
  • Re: Why do you use XML?
    ... different flavours of CSV. ... Sometimes you wrap all strings in quotes, ... we output to in this "standard" CSV format. ... The only benefit to XML is that someone already did most of the ...
    (microsoft.public.dotnet.languages.csharp)
  • Re: Why do you use XML?
    ... Sometimes you wrap all strings in quotes, sometimes you only wrap strings in quotes if they contain a comma. ... Our CSV output routines have a bajillion configuration options to accommodate all of the different systems we output to in this "standard" CSV format. ... The only benefit to XML is that someone already did most of the ...
    (microsoft.public.dotnet.languages.csharp)