Re: Symbolic AI: Why Marvin Minsky and Curt Welch Are Out to Lunch

From: "JGCASEY" <jgkjcasey@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
Date: 21 Jul 2006 14:52:05 -0700

Traveler wrote:

< ... >

. . . it is time that the GOFAI community realizes that
intelligence is not the result of symbol manipulation but
that the exact opposite is true. It is symbol manipulation
(a type of motor behavior) that results from intelligence.

If symbol manipulation results from intelligence what does
intelligence result from?

--
JC

.

Follow-Ups:
- Re: Symbolic AI: Why Marvin Minsky and Curt Welch Are Out to Lunch
  - From: J.A. Legris
- Re: Symbolic AI: Why Marvin Minsky and Curt Welch Are Out to Lunch
  - From: Traveler

References:
- Symbolic AI: Why Marvin Minsky and Curt Welch Are Out to Lunch
  - From: Traveler

Prev by Date: Re: Symbolic AI: Why Marvin Minsky and Curt Welch Are Out to Lunch
Next by Date: Re: Gradual Learning, not Reinforcement Learning
Previous by thread: Re: Symbolic AI: Why Marvin Minsky and Curt Welch Are Out to Lunch
Next by thread: Re: Symbolic AI: Why Marvin Minsky and Curt Welch Are Out to Lunch
Index(es):
- Date
- Thread

Relevant Pages

Re: Defining symbolic AI, what it really is and what its not?
... Traveler wrote: ... Symbolic AI is worse than evil. ... it's symbol manipulation that requires ... "A symbol is a partial state of a system ...
(comp.ai.philosophy)
Re: Symbolic AI: Why Marvin Minsky and Curt Welch Are Out to Lunch
... JGCASEY wrote: ... that the exact opposite is true. ... It is symbol manipulation ... (a type of motor behavior) ...
(comp.ai.philosophy)
Re: Symbolic AI: Why Marvin Minsky and Curt Welch Are Out to Lunch
... It is symbol manipulation ... (a type of motor behavior) ... the temporal relationships between unnamed signals. ... aversive sensory stimuli which are needed for adaptative behavior. ...
(comp.ai.philosophy)