Re: English Language Grammar

Hello Cybercyper,
Thanks for the reply.
But i still had a feeling that
In the sentence below:

He played music on the Mp3 player in his car, which was newly
purchased.

by just using a different conjuction (in this case "which") it gives a
different meaning.
e.g.

He played music on the Mp3 player in his car that was newly purchased.
=> This means the Mp3 player is newly purchased.
Correct me if i am worng.

=AD




On Dec 14, 4:01 pm, cybercypher <cybercyphe...@xxxxxxx> wrote:
ad <ajitsdeshpa...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote

I have a question.

A.]
Consider this statement below:-
He played music on the Mp3 player in his car, which was newly
purchased.

Now what connotation does this above sentence give , does it mean:
1.) that the MP3 player is newly purchased
Or
2.) that the car is newly purchased

It should mean that the car was newly purchased.

Now how do i change punctuation of this sentence to get above two
different connotations:

You can't do it that way. English is a word-order language, so you
have to move the "newly purchased" phrase in front of the "mp3
player" phrase, e.g.,

"He played music on the newly purchased mp3 player in his car".

What arrangement of the pronouns and the semicolon, give which
kind of connotation.

There is no such arrangement, and there is no semicolon in that
sentence, only a comma.

B.]
Under which Part of Speech of English Language grammer is this
kind of grammar covered ?

Modifiers, but a modifier is not a "part of speech" in the same way
that an adjective and an adverb are. Phrases can also be modifiers.

--
Franke: EFL teacher & medical editor
Native speaker of American English; posting from Taiwan.
"When you have to depend on those who used to depend on you, it's
time to say goodbye." Anymouse.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: English Language Grammar
    ... He played music on the Mp3 player in his car, ... you have to move the "newly purchased" phrase in front of the ... Modifiers, but a modifier is not a "part of speech" in the same ...
    (alt.usage.english)
  • Re: English Language Grammar
    ... He played music on the Mp3 player in his car, ... Now what connotation does this above sentence give, ... Phrases can also be modifiers. ...
    (alt.usage.english)
  • Re: Official "Whos the Luddite" thread, was Re: TVs
    ... Own iPod or MP3 player? ... That's what the radio is for. ... Has a hacked "disposable" digital camcorder? ... Primary car has GPS or a radio or requires a computer in the engine ...
    (rec.games.computer.ultima.dragons)
  • Re: Birthday gift for 14yr old niece?
    ... Sue (mom to three girls) ... home hi-fi to copy them onto a computer and then to the MP3 player. ... And then I listened to them in the car. ...
    (misc.kids)