Re: Gender neutral


Mike Lyle wrote:
mb wrote:
Tighe wrote:
[...]
There would be no gender issue involved here. [Sc. in German and Spanish]

Not here, but elsewhere. In fact, English has way, way less
interference of grammatical gender than a long list of different
tongues but surely it's the language that wastes the largest amount of
time, ink and saliva in the inane discussion of it.
[...]

But I think it's a political issue for English-speakers precisely
_because_ we don't have grammatical gender: our few feminine and
masculine forms do map to sex. Inclusive "he" is the only exception,
and we've seen that it's semantically unreliable in many contexts:
objectors to it aren't being stupid or needlessly picky.

No. It is part of feminist ideology, in which EVERYTHING is an
indication of brutish patriarchy.


I'd like it very much if so many surgeons, jockeys, and judges were
women that arguing about "he" really was the waste of time you suggest
it is; but, as things are, the argument is far from inane.

It is ideological, not linguistic. It is baseless and without merit.


--
Mike.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Gender neutral
    ... In fact, English has way, way less ... interference of grammatical gender than a long list of different ... tongues but surely it's the language that wastes the largest amount of ... but, as things are, the argument is far from inane. ...
    (alt.usage.english)
  • Re: Linguistic gender and perception
    ... language without grammatical gender like English is strictly necessary. ... If German/Spanish pairs like ... lead to consistent response patterns from test subjects, ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: Microsoft applications essential to the success of the Macintosh line.
    ... wake me up when you learn English. ... other people's conversations with irrelevant and inane comments. ... five-year-old has more communication skill than you. ...
    (comp.sys.mac.advocacy)
  • Re: More on Language, Whorf, thinking (hi, Fiona)
    ... between grammatical gender and sex. ... language besides English which is a member of a family with ... grammatical gender and which has mostly eliminated it. ... many words we have in English for those animals. ...
    (soc.culture.jewish.moderated)
  • Re: Microsoft applications essential to the success of the Macintosh line.
    ... wake me up when you learn English. ... other people's conversations with irrelevant and inane comments. ... five-year-old has more communication skill than you. ...
    (comp.sys.mac.advocacy)