Santa Cruz Serial killer Herbert William Mullin wants to go home and find a wife

March 23, 2006
Serial killer wants to come home

IONE - Herbert William Mullin wants to come home to Santa Cruz
County. He'd like to live in Boulder Creek and find a wife. He's
thought about auditing a psychology course at UC Santa Cruz. He says he
would be a hard-working, law-abiding citizen.

But Wednesday the California Board of Prison Terms refused to release
the convicted serial killer, saying he should stay behind bars for at
least another five years, the maximum time allowed between hearings.

Mullin was convicted in 1973 of 10 slayings in Santa Cruz County and
one in Santa Clara County.

The panel's action came after a roughly two-hour hearing at Mule Creek
State Prison, during which Mullin discussed his guilt, his life in
prison and his hopes for the future.

"I just want to get back to living my life free," the 1965 San Lorenzo
Valley High School graduate told the panel of two commissioners, whose
identities are kept confidential under prison rules.

Mullin's convictions stem from a five-month killing spree in late 1972
and early 1973. His victims included strangers and acquaintances, men
and women. He killed a woman and her two young sons, ages 4 and 9,
shooting them all in the head and stabbing the 4-year-old in the back.
He stabbed a 64-year-old Catholic priest in a confessional booth in a
Los Gatos church.

Though he was convicted in 11 murders, he's confessed to killing 13.

"This is ugly. These are very ugly crimes you've been convicted of," a
commissioner said.

As the commissioner recited the names of his victims and the
circumstances of their deaths, Mullin was calm, impassive, a lifted
eyebrow or turn of the head the only signs of any agitation.

Though he was argumentative at times, he maintained that composure
throughout the hearing.

"The people I am accused of killing, I did kill," Mullin said after the
commissioner finished. "But I'm not guilty by reason of insanity."

Mullin was 26 when he entered the state prison system. Now he's less
than a month away from his 59th birthday. He's a slight man, dwarfed by
the male and female correctional officers who escorted him, shackled,
into the hearing room. He's balding and wears large wire-rim glasses.

Though in 1973 Mullin said he killed to prevent earthquakes, he didn't
give that explanation when asked about his motivation Wednesday.
Instead he said he was suffering from "undifferentiated schizophrenia"
at the time.

"I was not a thinking individual," he said, blaming his parents for
"denying him maturity" and "not teaching me the facts of life."

His parents didn't explain the "pecking order" to him, he explained, as
an example, adding he's learned about the system of deference to those
in power while in prison.

"The state should be punishing my parents, at least chastising them
publicly," Mullin said. "They're the ones who made me do it. They put
me in a situation where I became mentally insane."

Mullin said his parents have since died.

Back then, Mullin said he was having a "terrible time." He took LSD and
marijuana, was in and out of mental hospitals, and sought outpatient
treatment in Santa Cruz.

But he's changed, he said. He's healed. He attends Alcoholics Anonymous
meetings, and hasn't taken any kind of medication since 1976.

He's taken vocational courses in cooking, landscaping and cabinetry,
and studied tai chi.

According to a prison report read at the hearing, he's worked as a
janitor for the past five years, and received positive evaluations from
his supervisor.

Mullin suggested grocery clerk or gas station attendant as possible
employment opportunities if he were released.

A commissioner reminded him the world had changed while he was in
prison, and that gas stations were now self-serve.

Mullin insisted he was ready to face the world, to be a benefit to
society and to demonstrate rehabilitation works.

"I'm extremely remorseful and sorrowful for my part in committing this
crime," Mullin said. "I pray for the souls of the victims every day."

But Santa Cruz County prosecutor Ariadne Symons, sitting a few feet
away from Mullin, said his "disregard for human suffering was
astonishing." He had no words for the families of his victims, she

As to his plan to seek shelter and help finding a job at New Life
Community Services in Santa Cruz, Symons said it's doubtful he could
find a place.

Symons said she serves on the agency's board, and those who seek help
there must accept responsibility for their actions, something Mullin
has never done.

"I don't care how well he behaves in prison," she said, urging the
commissioners to keep Mullin locked up. "Prison is also about
retribution. He's spent 32 years in prison and he hasn't begun to pay
his debt to society, not only for the 13 people he killed but also for
the families, the loved ones in this community."

Parole was denied because of the "cruel and callous" manner in which
Mullin carried out his crimes, the fact that he hadn't accepted
responsibility for them and the continuing danger he poses to society,
a commissioner said, explaining the decision to Mullin.

"You are not the victim here," he said. "The victims and their families
are the victims. You are the individual that made them victims."

Herbert Mullin's victims

Lawrence White, 55

Mary Guilfoyle, 24

Rev. Henri Tomei, 64

James Gianera, 24

Joan Gianera, 23

Kathleen Prentiss, also known as
Kathy Francis, 30

David Hughes, 9

Daemon Francis, 4

Robert Spector, 18

David Oliker, 18

Brian Scott Card, 19

Mark Dreibelbis, 19

Fred Perez, 72