Re: Motions of confidence



In article <gN6dndCga-jkEwjZRVnyjg@xxxxxx>,
"Graham Truesdale" <graham.truesdale@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Can the UK Commons use this to remove an individual
minister, as opposed to the Government as a whole?
Or is this privilege reserved to the Fourth Estate?

In effect, yes, the Commons can vote 'no confidence' in an individual
Minister. However, it's not done through a motion of no confidence
(traditionally) but by a motion to reduce the Minister's salary.

The last such motion unequivocally passed was in 1895 on Sir Henry
Campbell-Bannerman, Secretary of State for War, and resulted in the
resignation of the government.

A moment of confusion in 1975 resulted in the passing of a similar
motion on the Industry Secretary but it was reversed.

The Labour opposition attempted to pass such a motion on the Minister
of Agriculture over the BSE crisis in early 1997 but did not quite
get the votes.

--
http://www.election.demon.co.uk
"We can also agree that Saddam Hussein most certainly has chemical and biolog-
ical weapons and is working towards a nuclear capability. The dossier contains
confirmation of information that we either knew or most certainly should have
been willing to assume." - Menzies Campbell, 24th September 2002.
.



Relevant Pages

  • Motions of confidence
    ... Can the UK Commons use this to remove an individual ... minister, as opposed to the Government as a whole? ... Treasure in heaven is exempt from death duties. ...
    (alt.talk.royalty)
  • RM4.6 billion PKFZ scandal - third Transport Minister to be marred and tarred?
    ... RM4.6 billion PKFZ scandal - third Transport Minister to be marred and tarred? ... Datuk Ong Tee Keat following my statement welcoming his ... welcomed his pledge of government accountability and transparency on the RM4.6 ...
    (soc.culture.malaysia)
  • Interview of Slovenias former Justice Minister Dr Lovro Sturm
    ... Former minister of Justice Lovro Sturm points out that in a moment ... when the police minister demands destruction of the public ... the government does not care about it we may justly express doubts ... whether we may still speak about Slovenia being a modern state ...
    (soc.culture.austria)
  • Interview of Slovenias formert Minister of Justice Dr Lovro Sturm
    ... Former minister of Justice Lovro Sturm points out that in a moment ... when the police minister demands destruction of the public ... the government does not care about it we may justly express doubts ... whether we may still speak about Slovenia being a modern state ...
    (soc.culture.croatia)
  • Interview of Slovenias former Justice Minister Dr Lovro Sturm
    ... Former minister of Justice Lovro Sturm points out that in a moment ... when the police minister demands destruction of the public ... the government does not care about it we may justly express doubts ... whether we may still speak about Slovenia being a modern state ...
    (soc.culture.europe)