Re: Battenberg/Teck "renunciations" (was Re: Cascading errors at Buyers' "Royal Ark"


susuhanan@xxxxxxxxxxxxx a écrit :

Guy Stair Sainty wrote:
In article <1150179342.338552.281790@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>,
susuhanan@xxxxxxxxxxxxx says...


pierre_aronax@xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
susuhanan@xxxxxxxxxxxxx a =E9crit :


What happens when such a person, who say has lived in the US and has
changed his name there, and become a US citizen, then travels to France
on his US passport and is admitted to France in the usual way. His visa
has been accepted and immigration have stamped his passport on entry to
French territory, i.e. the French state has recognised his US legal
personality.

Hasn't France then accepted his US legal personality? Or does French
law treat him as a fraud, impersonator, or someone using a false
identity?

A Visa stamp is not in any sense an acceptance of someone's legal personality!

I know how difficult these things are for you, but if you care to read
the post, it did not say merely "a visa stamp" did it? I

Where do you get that idiotic idea. It is merely a permission extended to the
person bearing the passport concerned to enter the country according to certain
conditions. No foreign state can alter one's civil state in France (or Spain, or
Italy, or Germany, to name just three other countries which have very precise
laws regarding nomenclature).

Then how do you explain the German state's treatment of Prince Louis of
Battenberg as an enemy alien when the Great War broke out?

If what you say is true, but do not demonstrate beyond merely stating
your opinion, then he would have been treated as a traitor.

To give you an example of how such matters are governed, I know of a case where
a French citizen (a member of a royal house), married a member of another royal
house in her own country; she was then divorced in the country of her husband
but failed to register this with the French authorities (he remarried); she
remarried civilly in a third country and divorced there. Now she wishes to
remarry but her name changes mean that she has two completely different names in
2 European jurisdictions and it has taken more than a year of back and forth to
get all the documentation up to date.

Seems to do with registering or not registering a divorce. As usual,
Sainty cannot pursue his argument, so it has to be diverted down some
unrelated byway. All the better, if it gives him an opportunity to
boast about knowing so and so Prince this, or Arbishop that, or some
minor nobody who is a Knight of Malta.
Names are dropped!

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Press "1" for English
    ... France told you not to go in Iraq,you didn't listened,you pay the price,and ... his country to figure out how change sides at the last minute, ... There is a difference between losing a war and losing interest. ... The French in Africa? ...
    (alt.security.alarms)
  • Re: The 2006 election
    ... BTW The French language Canadian newspapers, ... Cochon Capitaliste used to be Capitalist Pig. ... incarnation, he was one of the biggest bashers of France, ... You live in a formerly socialist country that has suffered ...
    (soc.retirement)
  • Reasons for Dissension between France and USA
    ... I'd like to talk about France, it's a country I know pretty well. ... denigrate other politicians, including the president of the republic, ... against those who oppose the opinions of the French "Danube ...
    (soc.culture.british)
  • Reason for dissention between France and USA
    ... I'd like to talk about France, it's a country I know pretty well. ... denigrate other politicians, including the president of the republic, ... against those who oppose the opinions of the French "Danube ...
    (soc.culture.australian)
  • Reason for dissention between France and USA
    ... I'd like to talk about France, it's a country I know pretty well. ... denigrate other politicians, including the president of the republic, ... against those who oppose the opinions of the French "Danube ...
    (soc.culture.british)