Re: My "One Touch Meter" test-off



On Mon, 25 Aug 2008 17:47:59 -0700, anon aka wrote:

I ordered a free One Touch Ultra 2 meter from their web site last week.
It came today, it included the whole kit, 10 strips, control solution,
diabetes DVD etc.

This made 4 One Touch Ultra meters for me. I have a One Touch Ultra (5+
years old), a One Touch UltraSmart (2+years old), a One Touch Mini (1
year old), and now the One Touch2 (new). I lined them all up and with
the same vial of strips did the control solution test on them. The
results were:

One Touch Ultra = 125
One Touch UltraSmart = 125
One Touch Ultra Mini = 126
One Touch Ultra2 = 118
The control was 103 - 137 on the vial of strips.

Now I'm wondering if the 3 older meters were correct or if they made
impovements that made the new One Touch Ultra2 more correct.

anon aka

They did not "make improvements that made the new" one any better. The FDA
requires +-20%. The range on your control solution implies the maker
thinks the meters are good for about +-15%. The numbers you got are all
well within both margins of error. You cannot conclude that any of them
are any 'better' than any of the others.
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Different meters....Different readings....??
    ... sugar levels. ... I recently got a new One Touch Ultra 2 to use to see how ... difference of 20 points between these two meters. ... I've found as much as a 10% difference from one vial of strips to another, ...
    (alt.support.diabetes)
  • Re: Question about the new? test strips
    ... these strips different from regular strips that I use in my one touch ultra? ... I use the same strips in each, my meters are a few years old. ...
    (alt.support.diabetes)
  • Re: Whats the point of control solution?
    ... I'm now using a Freestyle Flash and it does. ... Do I really need to check the meter every time I open a box of sticks? ... I've used control solution 3 times in well ... The one time I had a bad bunch of strips the ...
    (alt.support.diabetes)
  • Re: What do you use to carry your insulin/meter in?
    ... carry the meter, strips, some ponytail holders (I use them to get the ... a couple of extra lancets and the control solution. ... my meter is attached to my pump. ...
    (alt.support.diabetes)
  • Re: Meter discrepancies! What to do?
    ... > I picked up the meter today (Walgreens is the name on it). ... > I then tried it with the control solution from my One Touch Ultra. ... thinking I should have the same reading. ... > Both meters test ok with their own control solution. ...
    (alt.support.diabetes)