Nate Allen Signs, Eagles Release Mistake Alex Hall



By Bob Cunningham (Eagles Featured Columnist) on July 28, 2010

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/426269-nate-allen-signs-eagles-release-mistake-alex-hall

Only a few hours after second-round pick Nate Allen finally signed (after missing two days of camp), the Eagles released defensive end/outside linebacker Alex Hall—a piece they picked up in the Chris Gocong/Sheldon Brown trade.

So while it's great Allen is finally in camp and can start learning the defense he'll be helping to run, the fact that Hall was the guy to get the axe is sure to drive those of us who hated the Brown trade to begin with even crazier.

All we heard was that this kid was so athletic and was gonna be the next piece of the puzzle at SAM linebacker. Then the tune changed, and he was moved to defensive end.

For me, that was the beginning of the end.

A position switch usually means the team just doesn't know what to do with the guy. And for Hall, he didn't stay at linebacker very long.

They moved him to a position that is absolutely loaded with competition, including three draft picks, and the Eagles clearly weren't expecting much out of him.

So, in essence, they traded away two starters for a fourth- and fifth-round pick and a guy they didn't even want to keep around as a camp body.

I said it when it happened, and I'll say it now: this trade is going to come back to bite them, and it's going to bite them hard.

Ellis Hobbs is not the answer as a full-time starter on the right side, and as maddening as Gocong was, he could have been a very cheap and very effective backup.

They had better hope Brown has nothing left, Gocong continues to be a run-of-the-mill starter, and Trevard Lindley and Ricky Sapp both turn into All-Stars. Otherwise, this is going to be remembered as one of the worst moves of the Andy Reid era.

Speaking of trades, let's hope Allen turns into an All-Star as well, or the same shadow might be cast on the ill-advised Donovan McNabb trade.

P-Dub: Brandon Graham (DE) - where are you????

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Looks like Omar might swing and miss this off-season
    ... something out there that none of us can see via trade, ... team as a potential starter than to your own team as a set-up man. ... Gomez in a heartbeat before I'd trade Milledge. ... Schoenweis, El Duque, and Heilman ...
    (alt.sports.baseball.ny-mets)
  • Re: Looks like Omar might swing and miss this off-season
    ... As is the case with Heilman, Pelfrey would likely have more value to ... team as a potential starter than to your own team as a set-up man. ... I'm not sure the Mets have doubts. ... I think you diminish his trade value by putting him in the pen. ...
    (alt.sports.baseball.ny-mets)
  • Re: Trading For A WR?
    ... >> Bob McGinn, of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, reports the Philadelphia ... >> Eagles are reportedly looking to trade for a wide receiver, ...
    (alt.sports.football.pro.phila-eagles)
  • Re: Trading For A WR?
    ... > Bob McGinn, of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, reports the Philadelphia ... > Eagles are reportedly looking to trade for a wide receiver, ...
    (alt.sports.football.pro.phila-eagles)
  • Re: The final 53 is pretty much determined
    ... I think the Eagles have been trying to trade Hanson but nobody wants to ... Reid will probably keep an extra DE since Graham is injured and is probably ...
    (alt.sports.football.pro.phila-eagles)