Re: Just How Aweful Milledge Is


Bruce W. Goldstein wrote:
"Beach Runner" <Bob4Health@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1157389251.144032.298690@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Micheal Ray wrote:
"Beach Runner" <Bob4Health@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1157364843.993127.66020@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[...]


On
the other hand why on Dominican Republic were the send of time so
strong? When someone grew up in the Dominican Republic, the entire
tribe would all come down from the mountain, everyone singing and
dancing Meringue for days bringing produce to marked. These children
had extensive rhythmic training, and thus you'll find they had better
sense.

It's good to see Al Campanis is alive and well.

That was the culture of how the villages used to take the produce from
the
village to the market. It only demonstrates why these people were
*taught* from a young
age to have what other's consider a talent.


So if you're born without "it", you can be taught "it"??? Makes perfect
sense. NOT!!!



It's not saying there is any kind of selective breeding or natural
difference. Your analogy is false.

You need a long run on the beach, to clear your head..............

BWG

Bruce,

The run of the beach sounds great. Sadly, I'm leaving beachside in a
few
weeks, giving up telecommuting and doing a real job:-(

This simply means that most of what people think of as "Talent" is the
result of early experience and natural learning. This does not say
there
are no genetic components. But early learning has a far greater role.

Do you really think the children raised by over protective parents in
play pens
will gain the skills of toddlers that are climbing hills, running,
jumping, throwing
rocks, tumbling, spinning, trying to negotiate swings, bugs and the
like?

Do you think children raised by parents who play nothing but popular
rock
music will have anywhere near the ability to comprehend counter point
or
develop pitch than a child that is raised with parents that are
seriouis musicians,
practice scales, chords, sing to and with their children? That
children
listening to counter point, Count Basie, 12 tone rows, Duke Ellington
won't
have a huge advantage.

Do you really ignore the MRI studies of structural developments in the
brain
from young music students?

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: To rmp Parents....music during labor?
    ... dig under rocks wrote: ... Any of you parents out there in rmp land have music in the birthing ...
    (rec.music.phish)
  • Re: Just How Aweful Milledge Is
    ... But early learning has a far greater role. ... Do you think children raised by parents who play nothing but popular ... music will have anywhere near the ability to comprehend counter point ... The ground work is exposing the child to music. ...
    (alt.sports.baseball.ny-mets)
  • Re: Rottie breaking window
    ... to several kids in the next yard throwing things at him ... (such as rocks). ... You've already talked to the parents too many times. ... your front yard, when your next-door neighbors are at home. ...
    (rec.pets.dogs.behavior)
  • Re: Rottie breaking window
    ... (such as rocks). ... You've already talked to the parents too many times. ... your front yard, when your next-door neighbors are at home. ... happens to my dog as a direct result (even if he eats a toy and chokes or ...
    (rec.pets.dogs.behavior)