Re: Best comment from Judge Vinson's decision

On Sat, 05 Feb 2011 08:44:42 -0800, Miss Elaine Eos wrote:
On 2011-02-04 19:41:34 -0800, Carbon <nobrac@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>

Just to be clear, I am not advocating [...whatever -- snip]. I would
just like something for the bottom third of the population as a means
of controlling healthcare costs.

If you have any bright ideas, we're all ears.

Just for the record, though, you're not the only one who's thought about
this quite a bit... ;)

Misc "turns out: it's a hard problem with no simple answers."

Very much agree with that.

My idea: a hybrid system. The poor get universal healthcare. It is not
great but better than nothing. Everyone is required to pay into it. The
wealthy can continue to purchase whatever insurance they like from their
friendly neighborhood insurance agent, just like they do now. With proof
of insurance at or above the level of the universal system, they get a
tax break due to not participating in the universal system. Healthcare
costs as a percentage of GDP goes down. ALE goes up if anyone cares about

Everyone pays something. Aside from lower premiums, the well to do will
see very little change.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Best comment from Judge Vinsons decision
    ... of controlling healthcare costs. ... The poor get universal healthcare. ... friendly neighborhood insurance agent, ... tax break due to not participating in the universal system. ...
  • Pelosis Hideous Flapping Turkey Neck Frightens Even Seasoned Reporters
    ... Democrat's Healthcare Strategy: Attack Insurance Industry to Push ... Stung by poll after poll showing them steadily losing ground on the ... The polling explains Obama's frequent refrain that the public-option ...
  • Re: Clinton unveils socialist medical plan
    ... businessperson provides zero healthcare insurance funding for 10 employees ... and less of the portion of the employees healthcare insurance cost. ... insurance industry we have gobs of payers too. ...
  • The Politics Of National Health Care Reform
    ... The Politics of National Health Care Reform: ... people are terrified over the healthcare issue today. ... mandate that every person purchase health insurance. ...
  • Re: OT: Affordable healthcare
    ... than a medicare buy-in or single payer. ... force people to buy insurance from private companies but the ... profits come from the investment pool that backs the insurance. ... cost for healthcare will rise. ...