Re: EOL's

Correct Robert, I don't remember the tolerance band on this particular
resistor but I believe it to have been a 10% Silver. That would mean it
would have had a high range of 4.114k but it was at 5.86k that would be
56.7% increase in value. We will never know what happened to have changed
it so drastically.


"Robert L Bass" <sales@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:eb6ev1h97at7kufj9b3amplqddkrkuemuu@xxxxxxxxxx
If you begin with a resistor with a 20% tolerance (no tolerance band),
and with some age and heat, the carbon in it can change it's
resistive/conductive properties...

No Al. That is not correct. Tolerance is a measure of the
precision of the resistor in manufacturing. It does not mean
that the resistor will change over time.

Resistors are never made to the exact value indicated by the
color codes. Manufacturers use the tolerance color band to tell
you just how accurately the resistor was made. It is a
measurement of the imperfections. Gold = within 5% of dead-on.
Silver = within 10%. In other words, the tolerance band
indicates the range of possible values that a given resistor may
have. For example, a resistor with three red bands and one gold
band is rated at 2200 Ohms but it can actually read anywhere from
2090 to 2310 Ohms. Whatever its value was when made, it will
remain at that same value permanently.

To determine the exact range that the resistor may be, take the
value of the resistor and multiply it by 5%, 10%, or 20% for
gold, silver or no tolerance band, respectively.

If you really want to control this better, try either 10% tolerant
resistors (silver tolerance band) or better yet 5% (gold tolerance
band) resistors.

The above statement is based upon a misunderstanding of resistor
tolerance.

If you really want to be picky, use 5-band resistors but have fun
finding an alarm manufacturer that supplies them. 3-Band and
5-band resistors do exist, though they're not appropriate for use
in alarm circuits.

It is highly unlikely that the gentleman has a 20% tolerance
resistor but even if he did that would not mean that the carbon
is more likely to change value.

--

Regards,
Robert L Bass

Bass Burglar Alarms
The Online DIY Store
http://www.BassBurglarAlarms.com

--

Never underestimate the power of very stupid people in large
groups.


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Fuseable resistor value.
    ... I read it as 24.4 at 10% tolerance, ... the third yellow band ... But why a 2W 240K resistor in something that is unlikely ever to have ... logical but silver 10 percent makes no sense at all. ...
    (sci.electronics.repair)
  • Re: EOLs
    ... I can assure you that Bass is not telling the truth on the issue. ... Nutone Service Center... ... Perhaps if you had learned a thing or two about resistor ... You tried to explain resistor tolerance ...
    (alt.security.alarms)
  • Re: EOLs
    ... of the firm was Alarm & Communications Co. ... Nutone Service Center... ... Perhaps if you had learned a thing or two about resistor ... You tried to explain resistor tolerance ...
    (alt.security.alarms)
  • Re: Creating a higer wattage resistor
    ... It would be much more likely that the second resistor ... I have requested the statistical distribution of resistors from resistor ... the tolerance set at the 3 standard deviation points. ... I needed a 2.5 ohm SMD resistor but the company didn't have any in stock ...
    (sci.electronics.basics)
  • Re: Excel resistor tolerance calculator
    ... following little Basic routine in one of the free magazines. ... accepts a resistor value that perhaps came from an exact calculation, ... tolerance range. ... Since the routine above would give the mathematically correct value ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
Loading