The Concept of Eternal Damnation in Islam


drahcir wrote:
Hey 1boy, you know, it seems you forgot to make a retraction of and
apology for one of the myriad lies you make here at ari. This
particular one was proven wrong by yours truly. Here, let me refresh
your memory:

From the thread A Psychiatrist Destroys Islam

I don't think Islam is any more violent than Christianity or Judaism
is.

You say that primarily because you are a despicable liar. There is no
way judaism is responsible for anywhere near the number of murders done
by muslims in india alone, let alone the rest of the world

P.S. When you are demonstrating the millions upon millions of people
killed by jews, aim for about 80 million for starters:

Historian Will Durant wrote in The Story of Civilization (1972) that
the Muslim conquest of India was "probably the bloodiest story in
history." The number of people killed is estimated based on the Muslim
chronicles and demographic calculations. K.S. Lal estimated in his book
The Growth of Muslim Population in India that between 1000 CE and 1500
CE, the population of Hindus decreased by 80 million.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_conquest_of_South_Asia

Drahcir, as you already know, I don't like to have any discussion with
you. I will answer your post this time but don't make it a habit of
answering my posts. It is best that you go away and find some other
newsgroup in which there are Muslims.

I have answered this foolish lie, spread by Hindu fundamentalists, too
many times already.

Durant was no expert on Indian history and used Smith's biased Oxford
History of India as his single source, and therefore he is not very
credible on this issue. Some of this fiction was started by Muslim
historians who exaggerated military exploits of their own kings in
poetry and by modern Hindu writers who took these writings as facts
without any critical analysis. It is an established historiacl fact
that thousands of Hindus served in the "Muslim" army. Sultan Mahmud
Ghaznavi, accused of launching 17 raids in northern India, is perhaps
the most despised Muslim ruler in Indian history but his own general,
Tilak, was a Hindu. It was also common in those days for rival Hindu
rajas to destroy temples of rival gods after massacring enemy soldiers.
What's usually forgotten is that if Muslim Indian kings were cruel,
they were also cruel towards Muslims and occasionally did not even
spare their own brothers, fathers and other relatives.

It must also be said that because of evil social practices, Hindus
brutalized each other. Inhuman treatment of untouchables, such as
pouring hot oil into their throats if they insulted Brahmins, and
burning widows were common practices in India before the arrival of
Muslims.

The lie about 70 or 80 million Hindus killed originated with Indian
Professor K.S. Lal's book "Growth of Muslim population in India", who
wrote that "according to his calculations, the Hindu population
decreased by 80 MILLION between the year 1000 and 1525." I don't have
his book, so I am not sure if Professor Lal's was implying that Muslims
killed these 80 million or if that population became reduced because of
some other reasons. In any case, the number seems highly unrealistic
given the fact that the entire population of India, Pakistan and
Bangladesh was not more than 350 million in 1947. So, if you calculate
backwards and allow for normal population growth rates, you would
realize how ridiculous Professor Lal's assertion is. Judging from the
title of the book, my guess is that Professor Lal was simply trying to
explain the high percentage of Muslims in India by making a point that
this percentage would have been much lower if so many Hindus had not
died during the Muslim rule.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: The Concept of Eternal Damnation in Islam
    ... So the Muslim 1BOY DUDE he does not have to disprove anything. ... official level by India and Bangladesh. ... but minority Hindus lost power. ... The report was so critical of Pakistan Army ...
    (alt.religion.islam)
  • Re: OH! YOU!! HINDU AWAKE!
    ... Muslim Persecution of Hindus In India -- The Story You Won't See In ... there are a few very brave Hindus who are taking a stand ... against the Muslim terror campaign in India. ... As Ghosh emphasized in our interview, the Muslim persecution of Hindus ...
    (alt.religion.islam)
  • Re: Madrasas are centres of social service - Home Minister Shivraj Patil
    ... Hindus especially the top echelons of them ... than it was when Babar attacked India. ... that Pakistan would give up transmission the raison d'etre to its ... of Muslim League in 1940. ...
    (soc.culture.indian)
  • Re: Under Islam - the Dhimmi System
    ... They slaughtered Hindus by ... and Muslim historians are on record as exulting ... Is Pakistan so powerful that India is forced to ...
    (soc.religion.islam)
  • Re: The Concept of Eternal Damnation in Islam
    ... Was There an Islamic "Genocide" of Hindus? ... Nandan Vyas ("Hindu Genocide in East Pakistan", Young India, January ... Once Muslim power was ... Braudel wrote in A History of Civilizations (Penguin 1988/1963, ...
    (alt.religion.islam)