Re: Nicolas Croiset's lies

"DAB sounds worse than FM" <dab.is@dead> wrote in message
news:9KYxh.131$WD6.88@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Malcolm Knight wrote:

I don't read Nicolas Croiset's comments (life's too short) but if he
is saying that FM won't give better than 40dB SNR then he truly is
everything Steve says he is.

Here's some links to his claims:

http://groups.google.com/group/alt.radio.digital/msg/0cf245f73590f70f?hl=en&;

"The S/N is not 70dB in stereo (and mono also), the best value is
around 40dB, not more."

http://groups.google.com/group/alt.radio.digital/msg/c550114a6b4447a3?hl=en&;

"Yes the SNR is around 40dB when you receive FM very well without any
multipath. There is not so many people which can receive FM in this
condition."

Absolutely ludicrous. Has he no practical experience of listening?

I'm sure R.L. would have had the same experience and recollections,
it'd be interesting to see if he confirms the above.

Richard L will just excuse his protege's indiscretions.

RL. is very selective with his replies. I'd doubt he'd get anywhere near
supporting the view that "when you receive FM very well" it has a
background like a steam train.
--
Malcolm.


.