Rescuing the Rust Belt
- From: jose <josefsoplar@xxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Fri, 7 Mar 2008 07:56:21 -0800 (PST)
Rescuing the Rust Belt
By Thomas Sowell
Tuesday, March 4, 2008
It is fascinating watching politicians say how they are going to
rescue the "rust belt" regions where jobs are disappearing and
companies are either shutting down or moving elsewhere.
The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) is being blamed for
the jobs going elsewhere. Barack Obama blames the Clinton
administration for NAFTA, and that includes Hillary Clinton.
Senator Obama says that he is for free trade, provided it is "fair
trade." That is election year rhetoric at its cleverest.
Since "fair" is one of those words that can mean virtually anything to
anybody, what this amounts to is that politicians can pile on whatever
restrictions they want, in the name of fairness, and still claim to be
for "free trade." Clever.
We will all have to pay a cost for political restrictions and
political cleverness, since there is no free lunch. In fact, free
lunches are a big part of the reason for once-prosperous regions
declining into rust belts.
When the American automobile industry was the world's leader in its
field, many people seemed to think that labor unions could transfer a
bigger chunk of that prosperity to its members without causing
economic repercussions.
Toyota, Honda, and others who took away more and more of the Big Three
automakers' market share, leading to huge job losses in Detroit,
proved once again the old trite saying that there is no free lunch.
Like the United Automobile Workers union in its heyday, unions in the
steel industry and other industries piled on costs, not only in wage
rates having little relationship to supply and demand, but in all
sorts of red tape work rules that added costs.
State and local governments in what later became the rust belt also
thought that they too could treat the industries under their
jurisdiction as prey rather than assets, and siphon off more of the
wealth created by those industries into state and local treasuries
with ever higher taxes -- again, without considering repercussions.
In the short run, you can get away with all sorts of things. But, in
the long run, the chickens come home to roost. The rust belt is where
those rising costs have come home to roost.
While American auto makers are laying off workers by the thousands,
Japanese auto makers like Toyota and Honda are hiring thousands of
American workers. But they are not hiring them in the rust belts.
They are avoiding the rust belts, just as domestic businesses are
avoiding the high costs that have been piled on over the years by both
unions and governments in the rust belt regions.
In short, the rust belts have been killing the goose that lays the
golden eggs. That is a viable political strategy, so long as the goose
doesn't die before the next election and politicians can avoid leaving
their fingerprints on the weapon.
But the people who lose their jobs, and who live in communities that
decline, need to look beyond the political rhetoric to the grim
reality that there is no free lunch.
Many workers in the new plants being built by Toyota and others
apparently already understand that. They have repeatedly voted against
being represented by labor unions. They want to keep their jobs.
Where does NAFTA come into the picture?
International trade is just one of the many ways in which the
competition of lower cost producers can cause higher cost producers to
lose customers and jobs. Technological improvements or better
management practices by domestic competitors can have the same
result.
Jobs are always disappearing. The big question is why they are not
being replaced by new jobs. Rust belt policies that drove out old jobs
also keep out new jobs.
NAFTA makes it easier for politicians to blame the problem on
foreigners. In fact, foreigners make ideal scapegoats for politicians.
After all, people in Japan or India can't vote in American elections.
Americans who can vote would do well to start spending more time
thinking about economic realities, instead of being swept away by
political rhetoric.
.
- Prev by Date: President Numb Nuts adds one more thing to his stellar resume....
- Next by Date: Job losses worst in 5 years - thanks Bush
- Previous by thread: President Numb Nuts adds one more thing to his stellar resume....
- Next by thread: Job losses worst in 5 years - thanks Bush
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|
