Re: Is there a preferred structure for navigation links?

In article
<49ab637d$0$4211$5a62ac22@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>,
"asdf" <asdf@xxxxxxxx> wrote:


I'm with Nige on this one...

I never take sides...

cf. your statements above, my naughty editing bringing the contradiction
out in relief... <g>

1. It is wrong (and would be very surprising) that the 'semantic markup'
ethos implies you should *never* *ever* use a one col or one row table.
a consequence of your assertion above.


No, because from *accessibility and semantic* standpoints, a menu is not by
nature tabular data. Arranging menu items using tables implies
(semantically) that the coder is presenting data rather than UI elements.


How do you come to the idea that a menu is not tabular data?

If, on the other hand, you DID have some tabluar data to display (like maybe
database records containing a single field (your example) or single record),
then it is perfectly acceptable, indeed it would be CORRECT to use a table.

So why is a menu not suitable for a col or row? What is suitable? The
sizes of planets from Mercury to Neptune? (which I have urged, read
earlier, post in this thread to use an OL *preferably* Are you on "my
side" in this urging? or did you miss my urging for ULs and OLs as a
first choice).

Let's say the planet size figures are at least kosher on your reckoning
for a table.

So why not a menu exactly? Why not, really why? What is the argument
besides the utterance "it is not tabular data". It is the data of the
main menu items on the site. or it is the data on the local menu items
on the page.

Note that tables, semantically speaking *should* contain 'header' rows as a
minimum to explain what the data actually is, even if you style them to be
invisible.

I would say this is untrue but I am willing to hear your argument for
this. No quotes from authority figures please, not interested in these
unless you tell them to talk to me directly. The context alone could be
all the information a user would need to understand what is going on
without <TH>s (assuming you are talking these latter). If you had a
paragraph beforehand to give context or a heading saying "Planet sizes",
there would be no need. Same with menu items not needing any particular
formal heading preceding. It can be obvious.

I guess what I'm talking about here is 'best practice' as opposed to
'acceptable practice'.

Best practice is not on the same road that leads to people refusing to
use tables when tables are in fact kosher. Pretty well every week in
some periods, we get examples of these thoroughly frightened
individuals. Your's and Nige's mistake is subtler but no less an error
imo.

....

3. A two col table is very much a thoroughly correct *option* (not
requirement) for an ordered list, the order being in one col and the
list items in the other.

Ah no. A table by it's very nature should not rely on order of data
necessarily,

This is either too vague, irrelevant or plain wrong. The orders of many
of the lists in a table are very much *necessarily ordered*. Take a two
col table of products and prices. Once the products are set out in
whatever arbitrary fashion, the list of prices is then extremely ordered
or false info will result.

--
dorayme
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: How do you cope with Anxiety?
    ... The kind of "surgery tomorrow" anxiety would be to make lists of what I ... Practice and routine every day. ... All that tangent for a heart test ...
    (alt.support.arthritis)
  • Re: How do you cope with Anxiety?
    ... The kind of "surgery tomorrow" anxiety would be to make lists of what I ... Practice and routine every day. ... All that tangent for a heart test ...
    (alt.support.arthritis)
  • Re: Resiliency To New Data Requirements
    ... with the flawed theory of what was once known as 1NF. ... So I want to talk about theory and its relationship to practice. ... The industry had lists, then pooh-poohed ... Well, graph theory is constructed from set theory itself, a graph being ...
    (comp.databases.theory)
  • Re: vertical size calculation
    ... but as long as you understand what tabular data is. ... from tables to lists and immediately found that the list box height is ... How do you calculate table heights? ... should be the exact same height as they use the same CSS style class. ...
    (alt.html)
  • Re: vertical size calculation
    ... but as long as you understand what tabular data is. ... from tables to lists and immediately found that the list box height is ... How do you calculate table heights? ... is why are the heights of list boxes different from table ...
    (alt.html)
Loading