Re: BYOC 5-knob compressor finished


"Squier" <squier@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:160120092337173784%squier@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
Tony Done <tonydone@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

I just put the final touches this morning.

This isn't a complete test, but is based on a couple of amps and a couple
of
guitars, one of which has very noisy P90s in a noisy environment.

First, soldering irons. I used a $10 Nicholson 40w, no problems at all,
but
I did make fine point on it, got it very well tinned and cleaned it with
a
damp rag every time it started to tarnish. I blunt tip may be OK with a
25w
iron, but might have caused problems with this one.

The downloadable instructions were very clear, and the PCB was well
marked.
No electronic knowledge needed provided you read the instructions
carefully.

Populating the PCB was really easy, and all parts were present and
correct.
It certainly paid to spend a few minutes sorting and clearly marking the
resistors and caps before soldering. Even so, I managed to get one cap in
the wrong place and had to move it, no problem. I left the wires full
length, poked them through the board and bent them over to hold the parts
in
place. I then soldered them up in batches and cut them flush with fret
pliers (nail clippers would do). It doesn't look quite as neat as cutting
them before soldering, but I think it makes the job easier.

Installing all the connecting wires - there are a lot of them - was more
hassle than the PCB, and I'm now wondering if it wouldn't have been
better
to connect the wires to the PCB before the electronic components,
contrary
to the instructions. Also, all the hookup wire supplied is one colour. A
few
different colours would help if you were doing the wiring before the
electronics. Still, it worked out in the end.

The only thing that didn't work well were the SIP snap-off sockets for
the
BA6110 chip. It worked OK for the transistors, but wouldn't connect well
with the chip. I ended up holding it down with insulating tape.

How does it work? The compression only starts to show quack and OD when
sustain is turned up past 3 o'clock. The blend control is excellent, and
the
attack and tone controls are subtle. The compression itself is subtle and
fairly transparent below 3 o'clock. Not suitable for someone looking for
a
big up-front effect, it the kind of effect you only notice when it is
turned
off.

I think that at moderate sustain settings (less than 3 o'clock) the pedal
itself is effectively silent, but like all other compressors it will
amplify
guitar noises under some circumstances. When I played my noisy LP Special
in
my usual noisy environment the pedal didn't seem to add any noise to
speak
of. However when I laid the guitar on the floor to make some adjustments
it
was evidently in a bad spot for RF noise, and the pedal certainly
amplified
it. Interestingly, the noise subsided as soon I played a note on the
guitar,
definitely not just masking it. Not sure what was going on there.

The kit comes with a choice of two chips and two sets of diodes. I ended
up
using the BA6110 chip, which seems a bit less fuzzy than the CA3080, and
the
2N5088 transistors. I think these added a little more "grit" than the
2SC1849s.

All in all I'm pleased with the result, and I wonder if some of the
problems
with noise and distortion that have been reported are due to assembly
rather
than design or parts. Or, giving way to paranoia, it the performance of
my
compressor different from expectation because I did something wrong?

Tony D


thanks Tony - great report. I have some BYOC pedals but they
were made for me. (although I did build the fuzz which is a much
simpler pedal than what you built).
I was wondering about the noise - but it seems that it's quiet and
not adding in any extra hiss or noise which is good.

Sounds to be a good pedal by what you are saying
and they included every part needed.

one question though - Does it exhibit any of those annoying 'breathing'
or 'whoosing' artifacts ?
Some compressors can do this (although some only do it when the
sustain or attack is turned all the way up and don't do it with
any lesser settings).

If you are thinking about building one, I suggest you download the
instructions by way of encouragement.

The pedal didn't produce any of those strange compressor artifacts at all
with the pickups I tried (P90, SD Jazz), just a tendency to quack and
distort a bit at high settings. The sound has a slight grittiness which I
like, especially with the P90s, which area fairly "soft" pickup. Like all
good effects, the whole thing is subtle.

Tony D


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: BYOC 5-knob compressor finished
    ... one of which has very noisy P90s in a noisy environment. ... However when I laid the guitar on the floor to make some adjustments it ... was evidently in a bad spot for RF noise, ... I have some BYOC pedals but they ...
    (alt.guitar)
  • Re: a ramble about valve amps, power soaks and a question about noise gates
    ... run my valve amp with the master ... It's like the guitar ... hiss when certain fx pedals are on. ... back to noise gate pedals - anyone out there in UKMG-land got any ...
    (uk.music.guitar)
  • Re: BYOC 5-knob compressor finished
    ... one of which has very noisy P90s in a noisy environment. ... well with the chip. ... However when I laid the guitar on the floor to make ... I successfully modded a couple of OD pedals for ...
    (alt.guitar)
  • Re: BYOC 5-knob compressor finished
    ... one of which has very noisy P90s in a noisy environment. ... BA6110 chip. ... noise to speak of. ... However when I laid the guitar on the floor to make ...
    (alt.guitar)
  • Re: Oct 10 year ann Celebration
    ... Pedals are for people who cant play. ... Any more and its no longer music.Just noise. ... $2000 guitar. ...
    (rec.music.makers.guitar)