Re: Read?



On Jul 24, 12:29 pm, Pt <pea...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
I read several times that Lennon and McCartney (and Harrison) and
Hendrix did not know how to read or write music.
But somehow they managed to write hit after hit.
How could they write a song if they did not know what chords are in a
key?
How did they know how to phrase songs to fit with verse, verse,
chorus, verse etc?
Many of the Beatle songs have diminished and augmented chords in them
that stay in key with the music.
How did they do that?
Then there were songs with time changes to create tension like She's
so heavy.
How could they do that with no knowledge of music and song writing
techniques?

Pt

All of these musicians obviously could read and write music. They
just didn't see the need for doing so any faster than they did. And
this has nothing to do with "talent". The word "talent", in-and-of-
itself, explains nothing. Either you want to read and write, or you
don't. Nil, of course, is not satisfied with his own efforts, but he
wants me to qualify for him. The same goes for Tony now, it seems.
That Nil and Tony are now agreed that I might be full of bullshit
means that I must be doing something right. This matter of
credibility is a two-way street, people.

Mike
.



Relevant Pages

  • LA TImes: "Beating the Clock" (re. aging rockers)
    ... Scores of tribute acts over the years have filled clubs by playing hit ... The old songs may still sound great (and most of the musicians have ... Desert island album: ... Top ticket price: $454 ...
    (rec.music.artists.springsteen)
  • Re: Do you aim to please (in composing?)
    ... but too much of a hit song'. ... I stopped composing it further. ... which had like 8 songs and 4 of those were really catchy. ... of potential consumers, what do I do with it? ...
    (alt.guitar)
  • Re: Do you aim to please (in composing?)
    ... hit song people have too like it enough to buy it. ... industry is measured by money made and songs sold. ... surrounding yourself with limp dicks who dont want you to ever outgrow their ... Sometimes you just make a song that has that great catchy ...
    (alt.guitar)
  • Re: Asha, Lata, and RD Burman: Who Really Won Over RD Burman?
    ... work in doing this exercise but when the intelligence gathering itself is ... That 27% is for hit songs, and I sourced it from BGM annual and weekly ... lists, and my own research material on hit music. ...
    (rec.music.indian.misc)
  • Re: 4,000 Miles of Dream Theater :)
    ... Jake: HIT IT!!!! ... I did see that movie, ... ;) At least the speed limit in Nebraska is 75. ... certain songs sounded, which songs hit me particularly hard, etc. ...
    (rec.music.artists.queensryche)