Re: Self-Taught or Instructor



Which do you think is the best way to learn to play guitar? Self-taught or with an instructor.

I had the same thoughts and reasoning you did and found a balance. You
should go the path of teaching yourself and find some people to play
with. But still have an instructor who'll just answer questions and
analysis your playing to suggest where you need improvement or growth.
If your instructor can't do this, then maybe he sucks and needs to
follow the basic teaching program that the music store setups for him.
Ditch him and find someone else.

Oh, you'll never run out of questions or not need good analysis of your
playing. You may however out grow your instructor if his answers and
analysis grow stale. Just move on, or if your lucky, some of the guys
you jam with answer all your questions and gave you the analysis you
need.

As far as basic music theory, go take a class at a local community
college instead of wasting your guitar lessons. It's a different
discipline and once you're done, you can reference guitar books to see
how it relates to the guitar.

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: The hardest question on the written test
    ... I have never taught flying this way and would instantly fire any instructor I hired that I found using this method of teaching and/or approaching flying with this mindset. ... It's up to the instructor to impart to every student they teach that the trial and error scenario ends the instant the instructor turns the aircraft over to the student to go fly alone. ... It is absolutely imperative that the instructor teaches in such a manner that the student develops a flying mindset that is deeply embedded in a strong attitude that although perfection in the air may be unattainable, the seeking of that perfection is a never ending mindset that is so deeply ingrained in the student that the attitude developed is one of a zero acceptance for errors committed in the air. ...
    (rec.aviation.student)
  • Re: The hardest question on the written test
    ... When you start dealing with teaching people to do something that will kill ... The first thing you have to do when training a new instructor is to break ... the student, the trial and error scenario is fine. ... perfection in the air may be unattainable, ...
    (rec.aviation.student)
  • Re: What is the right academic institution for my musical growth?
    ... cheapest guitar possible. ... Middle, and high school band. ... Parents insist on college. ... fellowship - and most importantly - given job as teaching assistant. ...
    (rec.music.compose)
  • Re: I HAVE AN IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT TO MAKE
    ... Get a job teaching music ... Masterpiece known in the Universe the Nuclear Warrior Theme Song? ... Perhaps put out a notice on alt.guitar that I am now teaching a Nuclear ... Warrior Guitar Theory Course and only the most "Advanced guitar ...
    (alt.guitar)
  • Re: I HAVE AN IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT TO MAKE
    ... Get a job teaching music ... Masterpiece known in the Universe the Nuclear Warrior Theme Song? ... Perhaps put out a notice on alt.guitar that I am now teaching a Nuclear ... Warrior Guitar Theory Course and only the most "Advanced guitar ...
    (alt.guitar)