Re: Anakin Not Worth Saving


"Brett McConnie" <quadinaros@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:oxNZf.2132$vy1.1807@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
When I look at Anakin in the prequels I really don't see much that's good
in him. He only ever seems to be out for himself, everything's about him.
Even the cause of his downfall, his wanting to save Padme, is all about
him. "I can't live without her" he says. He should have been willing to
lay down his own life to save her but instead he gives up the lives of all
the Jedi so that he can gain the power to save her, for himself. What do
you think? Was there really anything in Anakin that was worthy of
redemption or was Luke misguided by the love for a father he never knew?

Are you saying the fulfillment of the prophecy should not have been?

Debbie Proctor
maraskywalker@xxxxxxxxxxxxx


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Anakin Not Worth Saving
    ... Even the cause of his downfall, his wanting to save Padme, is all about ... lay down his own life to save her but instead he gives up the lives of all ... Was there really anything in Anakin that was worthy of ...
    (alt.fan.starwars)
  • Re: Anakin Not Worth Saving
    ... In article, "Brett ... the cause of his downfall, his wanting to save Padme, is all about him. ... own life to save her but instead he gives up the lives of all the Jedi so ...
    (alt.fan.starwars)
  • Re: Anakin Not Worth Saving
    ... Even the cause of his downfall, his wanting to save Padme, ... up the lives of all the Jedi so that he can gain the power to save ... All I can say is I think the reason Luke was the only one who thouht there ...
    (alt.fan.starwars)
  • Re: Greek audiophiles...nuts or uber perfectionists?
    ... Because some people cannot live their lives without judging others and ... I find them wanting because, in various ways, they are spoiling the art ... One further thought about Yo-Yo Ma: the difference between him and, say, ... Itzhak Perlman is that Perlman, when he went on his klezmer kick, didn't ...
    (rec.music.classical.recordings)
  • Re: Christmas day?boxing day
    ... shopping, to sports games and just generally resume their lives. ... People don't necessarily need to generally resume their lives. ... Is that greed of the people wanting to buy bargains in the sales, ...
    (uk.railway)
Loading