Re: Max Rebo Band - before or after?
- From: "Nick Soapdish, Jr." <JGordon452@xxxxxxx>
- Date: 24 Dec 2005 16:23:35 -0800
And once again, Anybody becomes self-righteously offended if someone
even hints that Lucas could have made a bad decision. Sigh. Par for
course....yet again. (Of course, the best way to get a knee-jerk
reaction out of Anybody is to point out a plot hole- yes Virginia,
there ARE plot holes.)
Smon is right, you know. The new, revised musical number is the
_worst_ change Lucas could have made in the Special Editions. It is so
horribly jarring and ham-fisted in its "muppet appeal", that it makes
me cringe every time. Thanks for nothing, George. I could live with
Hayden being edited into the end of ROTJ, and even the alterations to
the Greedo/Han showdown can be accepted........but this drek? If Lucas
was afraid that the original musical number was "dated", he should see
how quickly that "Muppets imitate the Blues Brothers" number becomes
stale.
If he revises the OT again, he needs to correct that mistake. And
include an apology on the commentary track. Multiple times, too.
.
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: Max Rebo Band - before or after?
- From: Anybody
- Re: Max Rebo Band - before or after?
- References:
- Max Rebo Band - before or after?
- From: smontag
- Re: Max Rebo Band - before or after?
- From: Anybody
- Max Rebo Band - before or after?
- Prev by Date: Re: Biggest Feuds on AFS
- Next by Date: Re: I don't see a shoe in ROTJ
- Previous by thread: Re: Max Rebo Band - before or after?
- Next by thread: Re: Max Rebo Band - before or after?
- Index(es):