Re: When did Anakin pass the point of no return?

In article <1130474391.621344.25780@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>,
"atomic" <stereobahbah@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

> > Ah, but if you had read that quote you would have seen that it says "it
> > was said". That implies that nobody actually knows whether he really
> > could or not, ie. people like Sidious (or even Plagueis himself) have
> > said he could create life, but nobody has actually seen him do it. If
> > Plagueis could definitely create life then "it was said" wouldn't make
> > sense being in there.
>
> That's right!
>
> Plagueis could keep himself alive, he could cheat death - but it was
> NEVER confirmed that he actually DID create life.

Unless Plagueis turns out to be Qui-Gon, we have no proof that Plagueis
could "cheat death" either ... after all, he IS dead. :-)



> And that "it was said" statement is VERY important! Gives a clear
> indication IMO, that Sidious was merely trying to lure Anakin, while
> protecting himself from a recoursive where Anakin might say "you
> said......blah".
>
> Evidence to corobrate this is when Sidious says "we'll learn it
> together" (the ability to create life). Why would he say that if he
> already knew how??
>
> Nowhere does anything Sidious says imply an involvement in his creation.

Sidious is a liar. Very little that he says (if anything) is actually
true. It's all designed specifically to help get what he wants - both
the position of power and Anakin as his apprentice.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Did Darth Sidious create Anakin?
    ... Basically, just because Palpatine said the Sith could create life, it ... There are other reasons to suspect that Plagueis and/or Sidious ... And created Anakin, ...
    (alt.fan.starwars)
  • Re: When did Anakin pass the point of no return?
    ... >> together" (the ability to create life). ... That does not mean that Plagueis did not, ... Anakin asked him to help him ... So Palpatine is lying at some point. ...
    (alt.fan.starwars)
  • Re: When did Anakin pass the point of no return?
    ... > said he could create life, but nobody has actually seen him do it. ... > Plagueis could definitely create life then "it was said" wouldn't make ... indication IMO, that Sidious was merely trying to lure Anakin, while ...
    (alt.fan.starwars)
  • Re: Did Darth Sidious create Anakin?
    ... Basically, just because Palpatine said the Sith could create life, it ... There are other reasons to suspect that Plagueis and/or Sidious created ... And created Anakin, ...
    (alt.fan.starwars)
  • Re: Did Darth Sidious create Anakin?
    ... Basically, just because Palpatine said the Sith could create life, it ... There are other reasons to suspect that Plagueis and/or Sidious ... And created Anakin, ...
    (alt.fan.starwars)