Re: O&A kiss goblin and Mel's ass

On Tue, 5 Aug 2008 12:17:39 -0700 (PDT), american.male.1986@xxxxxxxxx
wrote:

On Aug 5, 3:10 pm, SapperPest19 <b...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:


So when you said "I agree that it could potentially have been
anything...but grammar was an odd choice", you didn't really mean that
grammar was an odd choice. You must have meant to say that choosing
was odd.

I would have said any choice but the right one was odd. Now if you
chose *correctly*, I guess I would have thought it odd that you
guessed, but I certainly wouldn't have said anything...except maybe
"Hey, good guess!"...but that's not what happened.

"any choice but the right one" implies that there is only one right
choice. Having placed no requirements on the criteria for making your
list and listing two unrelated reasons for the people on your list,
any reasonable person could conclude that any deficiency could meet
the criteria for making your list and, therefore, listing a deficiency
not be odd.

But that would have gone against when you said "It sounds
from your post like you're saying I put people on that list because
they made grammar mistakes. That was an odd thing for you to do."

Same thing: I would have said any choice but the right one was odd.


Oh, I understand now. You've been shown to be wrong so you are
changing your claim.

Nope, see above.


But I did pick something.

But you shouldn't have.

And my pick wasn't silly because of the
reasons I gave multiple times.

Yes it was. You could give your reasons a thousand times and it
wouldn't make a difference.

Yeah, my reasons showed why it wasn't odd the first time I posted
them. I just repeat them for the mentally challenged.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Starting page numbering 21 at page 21 but no numbering precedi
    ... I concur with that as there are two good reasons. ... "Suzanne S. Barnhill" wrote in message ... Even though I use StyleRef fields extensively, I still use a Next Page (or more often Odd Page) section break between chapters because I want to take advantage of "Different first page" to have no header on the first page of a chapter, as well as running heads throughout the rest of the chapter. ... For example, it is common to start Heading Level 1s on a new page, so adding PageBreakBefore to the H1 style achieves what is needed without resort to any manual breaks. ...
    (microsoft.public.word.pagelayout)
  • Re: Mallard (8-12)
    ... >One of the reasons I generally ignore the strip. ... Tinsley seems to have ... >a odd world perspective, like one might have if one read about how to ...
    (rec.arts.comics.strips)
  • Re: Dreamcatcher on the move
    ... On May 10, 10:03 am, "Nicholas D. Richards" ... intake for other reasons too..... ... but the odd couple now and ...
    (uk.rec.waterways)
  • Re: When it will be freed?
    ... "lack cohesion". ... I find that odd. ... other reasons write functions... ... Structure and Interpretation of Computer Programs ...
    (comp.lang.c)
  • Re: O&A kiss goblin and Mels ass
    ... grammar does not automatically eliminate grammar from being a ... it's not an odd one. ... any deficiency could be a legitimate reason to make your list. ... equal chance of causing someone to make your list. ...
    (alt.fan.howard-stern)
Loading