Re: A Couple of Questions
Welsh Dog wrote:
On Sat, 03 Jul 2010 15:58:16 -0400, John VanSickle
<evilsnackKOSHER@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Did the books decline in quality as quickly as the movies? If so, will
the final film actually be better than the book?
I loved *all* the books. I tend to look at the final three as 'One
book in three parts' which makes it a lot easier to follow since the
storyline is split over the volumes. :)
The films reached their nadir with GoF which was an utter debacle and
then improved... as films... although they have deviated dramatically
from the storyline to the extent I have *no* idea what's happening in
the final film.
However... from the latest trailer... amongst other changes, it would
appear that Harry and Voldemort have their final battle outside
Hogwarts and not in the Great Hall!
Looks to me like they are dueling in the remains of the castle. There
are a few crumbly walls around them.
Regards,
John
---
news://freenews.netfront.net/ - complaints: news@xxxxxxxxxxxx ---
.
Relevant Pages
- Re: Spiderman 3 DVD
... The film was weak. ... I think their storyline jumped the shark when the two of them were ... the movie were actually with Topher Grace playing off of Toby, or Venom ... I'd suggest that Raimi should've cut Sandman ...
(rec.arts.movies.current-films) - SPIDERMAN 3
... The storyline seemed diluted, with it branching off as it rolled along, and while it logically made sense, only a few scenes stood out as having any really deep emotional impact. ... The film didn't have the tight focus the second film had, with its direct storyline and more relevant secondary stories. ... But these are just minor flaws, since the length of the movie makes them insignificant to the broader impact of the film, and are relevant only in comparison to what worked so well in the previous films. ...
(rec.arts.movies.current-films) - Re: The PS film
... several 'clues' in the film to events in the later books that she'd ... not written into the storyline but that Chris Columbus had slipped ... other day whilst watching the film that one might be Voldemort *flying ... and until DH when Voldemort attacked Harry ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter) - Re: The PS film
... not written into the storyline but that Chris Columbus had slipped ... other day whilst watching the film that one might be Voldemort *flying ... and until DH when Voldemort attacked Harry ... Although she never specifically identified what it was that he said - one of the CLUES was in the POA movie - and supposedly when the three were together just after Harry and Hermione saved Sirius. ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter) - Re: HP6 movie question (spoiler)
... The books are what the storyline is all about... ... If in the film version of Frankenstein the ... minor technical change such as Ginny telling Harry where to find the ... Ginny hiding the tiara is *not* a minor change! ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter) |
|
