Re: Cho Chang not Ginny



Ron Hunter <rphunter@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
: Toon wrote:
:> On Sat, 22 Dec 2007 11:50:14 +1100, Edward McArdle
:> <mcardle@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
:>
:>> In article <bfhnm3tpmscsthc6ne7c5fjieio696t539@xxxxxxx>,
:>> Toon <toon@xxxxxxxx> wrote:
:>>
:>>> On Thu, 20 Dec 2007 23:43:37 +0530, santosh <santosh.k83@xxxxxxxxx>
:>>> wrote:
:>>>
:>>>> Aaron wrote:
:>>>>
:>>>> <snip>
:>>>>
:>>>>> Now, if Ginny really did chase down the train in Book 1, something
:>>>>> I have missed in 4 readings, then perhaps that was in fact obvious
:>>>>> from the start.
:>>>> She did run a short way after the train, but there is no indication that
:>>>> she did so because of Harry. _All_ her brothers are leaving for school
:>>>> and she is going to spend a few months with just the adults back
:>>>> home and she cant wait to join them at Hogwarts next year, so it's
:>>>> understandable that she is slightly distressed at all her brothers
:>>>> going off to have a good time and she being left with domineering
:>>>> Molly. Running after the train for a short distance is quite normal.
:>>>>
:>>>> At that age, all she had was a silly pre-teen crush on the Boy Who
:>>>> Lived, nothing that would compel her to "chase down the train" as
:>>>> if this were a bitter parting of two lovers.
:>>> Of course, she did want to see Harry, once she knew who he was. It is
:>>> possible, but almost certainly not likely, she saw him sitting there,
:>>> and ran to gawk at him. But that's not so much love, as viewing a
:>>> celeb. Probably didn't start crushing on him to Molly went on and on
:>>> about Harry this, and poor boy all alone that. Then learning he and
:>>> Ron were BFF's only increased things, Miolly going on and on about
:>>> such a wonderful thing. Real love didn't arise till Ginny dropped her
:>>> crush, and became friends with Harry. Then it was all about who he
:>>> was, not what he did.
:>> Well, it always helps when a boy a little older than you saves you
:>> from extreme danger - in the first book you are in together!
:>
:> Yeah, but is it love, or gratitude? Would Ginny be as interested if
:> she never needed saving?
:
: She was interested before they met. She was still interested AFTER they
: met, even though Harry certainly wasn't what she had imagined the BWL
: might be. She was still interested after she was rescued, because she
: found that even though he wasn't what she imagined, he was,
: nevertheless, a real hero.
:
:> I'll never understand Pricnesses and their instinctual desire to marry
:> the first guy to save them. At least Fiona had a reason for wanting
:> her hero to feel something for her, to break her curse.
:>
:> And what of kings, always offering their daughters to the first hero
:> who saves them. Killing a dragon does not a great husband make.
: No, but it gets the daughter off his hands. Daughters in a patriarchal
: society are considered a liability, fit only for bargaining them off
: to someone for political advantage.
: Sorry about that, women's lib folks, but that is the way things WERE.

More practically,these kings are usually shown as being without sons,
and a dragonslayer would presumably make a good successor.But legitimacy
as a successor requires marrying into the old dynasty.

-=-=-
The World Trade Center towers MUST rise again,
at least as tall as before...or terror has triumphed.
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Question about "Battle for Bludhaven"
    ... I thought "The Monolith" by the ... Daughters of the Dragon is the same creative team as Bludhaven?? ... writers' output just varies wildly in quality from project to project. ...
    (rec.arts.comics.dc.universe)
  • Re: Question about "Battle for Bludhaven"
    ... Golly, a new troll! ... Nope, been posting since 1999. ... Daughters of the Dragon is the same creative team as Bludhaven?? ...
    (rec.arts.comics.dc.universe)
  • Re: Best starting point for Ethshar? OK to start with VA?
    ... Hero" does have connections with _The Blood of a Dragon_. ... Where can one find said short stories, and what are the others' names, pipes ...
    (rec.arts.sf.written)
  • Re: The Man Called Nova
    ... >their own book (Moon Knight, Spiderwoman, Daughters of the Dragon) or ...
    (rec.arts.comics.marvel.universe)
  • Re: Greatest martial arts movie of all time
    ... Kickboxer ... Hero ... I would probably go with Enter the Dragon as the best ... I think you can't do much better for a martial arts movie then ...
    (rec.martial-arts)