Re: OOTP

From: Toon <toon@xxxxxxxx>
Date: Thu, 24 Jan 2008 06:31:51 -0800

On Thu, 24 Jan 2008 05:12:38 +0100, "Lady of the Rings" <m@xxxxxxxxx>
wrote:

Well, sorry but... You all say DD might have been evile because he chose the
Potters andnot the Longbottoms. Since we do not have the Longbottom's death
date, we can't say that it was not around the Potters' one. Simply, The
Longbottoms have probably died in battle before the Potters, so Neville
might have been protected by gran.

All we know for sure is they were tortured after the Potters, and
lived as far as OOP.
.

References:
- OOTP
  - From: MAD Family
- Re: OOTP
  - From: John VanSickle
- Re: OOTP
  - From: Toon
- Re: OOTP
  - From: Alexandra
- Re: OOTP
  - From: Lady of the Rings
- Re: OOTP
  - From: Green-Eyed Chris
- Re: OOTP
  - From: santosh
- Re: OOTP
  - From: Green-Eyed Chris
- Re: OOTP
  - From: santosh
- Re: OOTP
  - From: Lady of the Rings

Prev by Date: Re: OOTP
Next by Date: Re: OOTP
Previous by thread: Re: OOTP
Next by thread: Re: OOTP
Index(es):
- Date
- Thread

Relevant Pages

Re: OOTP
... Since we do not have the Longbottom's death date, we can't say that it was not around the Potters' one. ... Simply, The Longbottoms have probably died in battle before the Potters, so Neville might have been protected by gran. ... I am also sure that Dumbledore knew exactly what families the Prophecy referred to immediately - and did not need Snape to tell him. ... Dumbledore would have gone to Sirius - and found out that Sirius was not the secret keeper - something Sirius COULD say. ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter)
Re: OOTP
... we can't say that it was not around the Potters' one. ... The Longbottoms have probably died in battle before the Potters, ... Dumbledore - as head of the OOP would have had ... Dumbledore would have gone to Sirius - and found out that Sirius was not ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter)
Re: Unanswered Questions
... We only know that he went to the Potters first - and was unable ... Longbottoms or Dumbledore felt that Voldemort would go after Neville. ... seem to know that Voldemort was going after Harry a year and a half ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter)
Re: Unanswered Questions
... - Snape hears the first half of the Prophecy. ... - He rushes off to tell Voldemort. ... Voldemort - knows it can apply to the Longbottoms and the Potters and ... - The Potters choose to go into hiding - and while everyone assumes ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter)
Re: Unbreakable Vow?
... :>But it is well-established that V killed Harry's father, not Snape. ... Snape's info did NOT lead DIRECTLY to the death of the Potters. ... satisfaction over having any involvement in bringing about James' death. ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter)