Re: The not so great Dumbledore

Toon wrote:
On Sun, 06 Jan 2008 15:59:25 -0500, Drusilla
<gammanormidsERASETHIS@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Toon escribió:
On Sat, 5 Jan 2008 18:04:07 -0800 (PST), Alexandra
<witchnicky@xxxxxxxx> wrote:

Personally, I felt Dumbledore was very cruel to Snape in that regard:
I found him cruel ever since Snape Aps in begging for help in saving
Lily. DD was a jerk to him. What happened to everybody deserves a
second chance? Then he's all, Oh so you only want Lily saved? As in,
why should I care if you won't care about her family. Maybe he's
really mad that Snape gave V the half prophecy, causing this to all
happen.
I think he actually never cared for Snape as long as he worked for him, and I mean truly cared about him and help him to change. As long as he takes care of Harry, he has no problem at all and while he can manipulate him because he knew his secrets, he knew he wouldn't leave. But not only Snape, he was manipulative with everybody else in many ways.

Yes, but he did it to save the world from Voldemort. Is the Greater
Good justifiable?

But hey, let's not debate that, let's debate if it's a good idea to
make DD gay.

Gee - I thought you didn't consider things JKR says outside of the books to be valid?
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: The not so great Dumbledore
    ... why should I care if you won't care about her family. ... I think he actually never cared for Snape as long as he worked for him, and I mean truly cared about him and help him to change. ... As long as he takes care of Harry, he has no problem at all and while he can manipulate him because he knew his secrets, he knew he wouldn't leave. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Snape: evil or not evil?
    ... we've said time & time again that Snape was not good. ... he didn't care if her ... vane as Regulus leaving because he mistreat his elf. ... on the real hero is just bizarre. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Hermoines Luck
    ... He was in a big hurry to get upstairs and take care of the Dumbledore ... In addition to killing a close friend of Harry's, the added bonus for Snape, if he is in fact a Death Eater working for Voldemort, would be offing a Mudblood. ... Snape could have easily killed Flitwick rather than just stunning him. ... If he had harmed Flitwick, Hermione, or Luna, it would introduce the possibility of them being found before Dumbledore was dead. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Snape: evil or not evil?
    ... we've said time & time again that Snape was not good. ... he didn't care if her ... vane as Regulus leaving because he mistreat his elf. ... JKR somehow ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: what i liked, disliked about HP DH (spoilers)
    ... Snape's thoughts were, in the pensieve. ... Why would he care? ... The only explanation I can give is that Snape hypnotized ... Harry when he asked him to look into his eyes, just before he died, ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)