Re: Harry's Detention In HBP

On Tue, 01 Jan 2008 15:32:02 -0600, Louis Epstein <le@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
wrote:

mueckelein <mueckelein@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
: On 18 Okt., 03:22, Weird Beard <weird_be...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
:> On Wed, 17 Oct 2007 04:53:20 GMT, Sirius Kase <SiriusK...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote
:> the following in alt.fan.harry-potter:
:>
:> > On Oct 17, 12:10 am, Tim Bruening <tsbru...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
:> > wrote:
:> >> For his detention after nearly KILLING Draco, Harry has to look through
:> >> the student discipline card files, and recopy any that are damaged. He
:> >> sees several mentioning misdeeds committed by his father, Sirius, and
:> >> Peter Pettigrew. I'm surprised that he didn't find any Snape misdeeds!
:> >> Didn't Snape ever do anything wrong?
:> > I believe they were organized in alphabetical order, and Snape had him
:> > start in the box where Potter, Black, and Pettigrew were. Interesting
:> > that Lupin isn't mentioned, I guess he was the good kid who couldn't
:> > keep his friends in line.
:>
:> You're making it too complicated: it was a rigged deck. All the Marauder
:> cards were purposley put into Harry's file, and all of Snapes (if any)
:> were removed.
:
: As far as I remember Filch was afraid of Snape and always did
: everything he wanted. Filch was very happy to hear of Harry?s
: punishment and will definately have removed the cards with Snape?s
: misdeeds - if they have been recorded. Filch seems to have been at
: Hogwarts already when Snape and the Marauders went there. Maybe he was
: afraid of Snape by that time already and didn?t memorise his actions
: on cards.

I think Filch would have lost his job if he falsified records like that;
and who'd hire a Squib?


DD'd forgive the first offense.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Wow....
    ... Snape had Dumbledore under the Imperius Curse the whole time. ... Without this requirement Filch is the obvious ... are Crouch, Fudge, Umbridge, and most Death Eaters. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Harrys Detention In HBP
    ... :>> I believe they were organized in alphabetical order, and Snape had him ... :> cards were purposley put into Harry's file, and all of Snapes ... Filch was very happy to hear of Harry?s ... I think Filch would have lost his job if he falsified records like that; ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: DH mistakes
    ... Chapter 33 has him receiving instructions from the portrait before ... and yet Snape was described as "talking to the portrait of ... then there was nobody there but Filch. ... When exactly did Voldemort take over Hogwarts? ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: DH mistakes
    ... Chapter 33 has him receiving instructions from the portrait before ... and yet Snape was described as "talking to the portrait of ... then there was nobody there but Filch. ... Or was the "sealing" done by the castle as a whole, ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: DH mistakes
    ... Chapter 33 has him receiving instructions from the portrait before ... and yet Snape was described as "talking to the portrait of ... then there was nobody there but Filch. ... When exactly did Voldemort take over Hogwarts? ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)