Re: Snape: evil or not evil?

It's time to name names...

The following are the 40 people who wrongly insisted that Snape was evil :

Akane Naruto, Alley Rabbit, Boo y Faau, Brent Braten, Chip Stobb,
Crookshanked, Dark Magic Shannon, David Harmon, Dinorider d'Andoandor,
Drusilla, Fred Z, G.J.W., Infinity Lamp, J.D.Tiger, Joe Curwen,
Jonathan Ellis, Joseph R. Moore, Kamara Fridley, Kami SW, Kasis 100,
Kevin van Dyke 777, Kish, Laura Ware, Lenona 321, Louis Epstein, LuLu
(Pilgrim Grey), Mike Bristow, Mishagam, Mooing Moo, Paul W. Lints Jr.,
Pygmy Puffs, Razor, Simon J. Dean, Slys Noodles, Spaminator, Stephen
Ray, Steve Morrison, Tim Peters, Troels Forchhammer, and Wizz.


These are the 6 people who sat on the fence, tut-tut : Bobby Durrettccci,
Kenny OMGTKK, Kilroy 1941, Knut J.Bjuland, Mauro, and Thom Madura.


And these are the 234 people who realised that, while Severus Snape should
never be described as being "good", he most certainly was not evil :

2000 Man, A.G.McDowell, Aaron, Abhishek Sinha, Adam JM 'in Denver',
Adds 21, AG30476, Akehanareru, Alex B. Clark, Alex R. Mosteo, Alpine
Wintergreen, Amy 'I explode', Amy Adams, Andrew Fishback, Andy Platt,
Angela Ho, Angrie Woman, Arielle Arlan, Arran M. Walker, Aselloth,
Astrodeb, Awesome Zachary, Babble 'Letters 2d', Baines Chile, Bajori,
Barbarossa Whewitt, Ben Arnall, Benjamin Esham, Blon Fel Fotch PDS,
Blue, Bob Sullivan, Bone Hammer, Booma, Bot Raviolissimo, Brian Tung,
Bruce E. Haddad, Bubbly Babs, C.Wotton 'Golightly', Cassie Wadkin
2000, Catherine Johnson FEnM, Cathy Weeks, CB 70, CH 'ez glide',
Charles Jones, Chickerific, Chimaera, Chip (R.Black), Christian
Potzinger, Christopher M (Pooh), Cie Je, Cold Hope, Consul, Cyde Weys,
D.M., D.S., Danse Macabre, Dave D, Dave Hinz, Dave Mc, David 'Plodma'
Joslin, David Foster, David M. Sueme, Deevo, DLH 'Roddleeh', Don
Reeves, Doofy, Doug Weller, Dr.Gong, Dr.Tim, Dragon Rider, Dreamer
728, Drifter, Dumbledore's Man, Duncan PA, Dwayne Ho, E.L.Keenan,
Eagle, Eggman 6, Eggplant, Emma Pease, Eric Bohlman, Fleeced, Freezer
88, Froggy (Shelly), Gaya 3, Gerhard Reichert, Gillian White, Ginevra
M.L., Grandmother Wolf, Green-Eyed Chris, Haladin Tacnar (Bill),
Helena Bowles, Here in Minnesota (Ken), HLK Pants CV, Homeboy 465,
Hoshisato, I.M.S., Idril Nargathr, Igenlode Wordsmith, Imagun Aqilya,
Inga WH, Isaac Kuo, J.J., James A. Wolf, James Cunningham, Jamie (the
Deli Gal), Jan van Aalderen, Jane Grey, Jano Devnull, Jason Lane,
Jayu, Jazon 48, Jean Lamb, Jess (Xu Chiang), Jim Hawkins, Jim
McCauley, Jim Utzerath, Joe Bednorz, Joe Gottman, John VanSickle, Jon
Mason, Jonathan Rodriguez, Josh Osubuckeye 5, Karen 'Trekker', Karnak
17, Ken NWC, Kenneth Stephen, Klaus Kassner, Kristen MD, Lady of the
Rings, Leslie Mills 2002, Lou Ann, Lucy (Ian 765), Lyle Francis Delp,
Lythande BlueStar, M.K.O 3, Marco Polo, Mark R1000, Mark Spiznet, Mary
Beth HP7, Matt Clara, Meghan Noecker, Mew Three, Mgurgeh, Mick
Hamblen, Mister E, Mueckelein, Murphoid, Mystic the cave, Nathalie
Cerridwen, Nedilus, Neener, Nella Frost, Nessa Zylstra-Wolf, Noesy
Parker, NSH Lord Potter 2005, Nukeman Alucard MD, Nuki Mouse, Nystulc,
Oddbit Roshade, Oly Ink, P.F.Gora, Paracelsus (Peter Sim), Parson Girl
125, Pascal, Paul Ciszek, Pawel FG, Peter V. Fox, Petrea Mitchell,
Ph0en1x, Philip Lewis, Photog, Pinky (Priyan Kaprad), Pip R. Lagenta,
Plodma, Poker Nose, R.Black, Riaan, Richard E. White, Richard
Fangnail, RLA 12, Rob Mac, Robert A. Neinast, Ron Hunter, Ruch Adalvi,
S.P.B., S.P.T., s0183616, Salman Rushdie, Santosh, Sara, Scenario
Dave, Septithol, Shadow, Shaun, Sick of Inaccuracies, Silvia Ludiana,
Sirius Kase, Sloeberdeef, Snape's Favourite, Spencer R. Lower, Sprite
Sue, Stacey 'Sita' Wesley, Stacy 68, Steven Sousa, Steven Szczech,
Straw, Sue H, T.Barry 22, Tamar (Richard Eney), Taunto, Tennant
Stuart, The Russ, Thomas Gagne, Tim Behrendsen, Toon, Toot, Trekker,
Trinity TAF, Tuvas, U.N., Ubuu 7, User 3247, Valerie in FL, Vikki
Quigley, Vinissime, Vipera Darcke, Weird Beard, Welsh Dog, Yarrow
(G.Kahn), Yogertlvr, Yuri Bolls, Zgirnius, and Zolak of Twylo.

Muchos Kudos to everyone in the big list!


Blon Fel Fotch Passameer-Day Slitheen

--
Free Margaret Blaine now!

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Snape: evil or not evil?
    ... The following are the 40 people who wrongly insisted that Snape was evil: ... And these are the 234 people who realised that, while Severus Snape should ... Barbarossa Whewitt, Ben Arnall, Benjamin Esham, Blon Fel Fotch PDS, ... Oddbit Roshade, Oly Ink, P.F.Gora, Paracelsus (Peter Sim), Parson Girl ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Snape, evil or not?
    ... Most people who believe that Snape is evil do so upon the basis that he ... teacher at Hogwarts (no, I don't think being a Catholic priest is even ... He sees Draco as the victim, and Harry as the bully. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Snape, evil or not?
    ... Snape is horrible, and if it wasn't for the control exerted over ... So how do you define "evil"? ... It's killing Dumbledore." ... "Dumbledore wears his heart on his sleeve, openly cares about Harry, ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Snape, evil or not?
    ... Most people who believe that Snape is evil do so upon the basis that he ... He was a priest in Poland, ... For him to be a good match for Snape, he would have to have: Voluntarily become a Nazi, mysteriously switched to helping the Jews after he was a Nazi, and, /after/ the war, after both his time as a Nazi and helping the Jews, found himself in a position of power, authority, and unavoidability over Jewish children comparable to Snape's position as a teacher at Hogwarts, and continued to treat them with hatred and contempt. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: A Silver Hand
    ... but DD picking up Harry and being seen with Hedwig is ... >>>Dumbledore did when he picked up Harry. ... >>>And honestly, Peter Pettigrew, of all people? ... But you must accept a DD wanting to die, Snape ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)