Re: What did JKR change her mind about, in your opinion, post-OotP? SPOILERS

On Aug 23, 10:29 am, Toon <t...@xxxxxxxx> wrote:
On Wed, 22 Aug 2007 14:51:14 -0700, lenona...@xxxxxxxxx wrote:

The main flaw with it was it relied on the next Book as ultimate
proof. Any theory needs to stand up on it's own, with future proof as
final proof, not the whole basis for proof.

Oh, I forgot - here's a biggie. What about the fact (as mentioned at
the K2K website) that since everything happens the same way twice in
PoA, including the slamming door and the thud of the ax, that means DD
(while in and near Hagrid's cottage, clearly helping at that time)
must have known BEFORE meeting with Sirius that he'd be helping
Buckbeak escape? Why would he do that, since Buckbeak isn't smart
enough to go into hiding anyway? Unless......

Lenona.

And for all we know, DD takes the TT from Hermione, goes back, and
leaves himself a note. DD doesn't have to know this stuff because he
used to be Ron and heard the H's tell him what happened.

Nice, except we never hear any hint as to how DD knew what to do in
advance. That makes it sound as though we're in for a bigger surprise.

Lenona.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: What did JKR change her mind about, in your opinion, post-OotP? SPOILERS
    ... Any theory needs to stand up on it's own, with future proof as ... not the whole basis for proof. ... (while in and near Hagrid's cottage, clearly helping at that time) ... Buckbeak escape? ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: What did JKR change her mind about, in your opinion, post-OotP? SPOILERS
    ... Any theory needs to stand up on it's own, with future proof as ... not the whole basis for proof. ... (while in and near Hagrid's cottage, clearly helping at that time) ... Buckbeak escape? ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Any help please
    ... My Niece has just got set up with BB her BIL has been helping her ... Does she have probs wit hSending them? ... Dave Lear Posted up a page abou tSettin gOutLook Express up. ... Tiscali have plenty of Info on their WebSite about it, ...
    (uk.people.silversurfers)
  • Re: Any help please
    ... My Niece has just got set up with BB her BIL has been helping her ... Does she have probs wit hSending them? ... Dave Lear Posted up a page abou tSettin gOutLook Express up. ... Tiscali have plenty of Info on their WebSite about it, ...
    (uk.people.silversurfers)
  • Contact Information Needed
    ... I'm helping the WSDC get some information together for their ... website and we are needing either direct contact information or ...
    (rec.arts.dance)
Loading