Re: Let's do a poll and find out who everyone believes is going to die in book 7

"Lyle Francis Delp" <Ldelp@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:200706071330458930-Ldelp@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
On 2007-06-05 15:44:25 -0400, blackmanblues@xxxxxxxxx said:

On Jun 5, 12:43 pm, Lyle Francis Delp <L...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
On 2007-06-05 12:07:12 -0400, "Matt Clara" <hey.woo...@xxxxxxxx> said:





"Dragon Rider" <fbru...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1180877661.005967.209950@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Matt Clara escreveu:
[interesting discussion snipped]
The fact that JKR wants us to question why DD had the cloak in no way
infers
anyone else was using the cloak. You'd need more evidence from the
books
to
pose such a theory with any credibility.

About the first phrase of your comment, I must say I agree. It has
often ocurred to me that the point of the question may be why did
James lend it do DD, not if it was being used by October 31st.

About your second phrase, I refer you to a passage in HBP, pg 49:

'I don't mean to be rude - ' [Uncle Vernon] began,
'- yet , sadly, accidental rudeness occurs alarmingly often,'
Dumbledore finished [...] 'Best to say nothing at all, my dear man.
[..]

'Nuff said.

In fact, the more I think about it, what you're saying is essentially,
"Now
that you've clearly shot this point down, rather than admit it, I will
instead call you names." What are you, 12?

Said the pot to the kettle, "You're black."

LOL! Didn't he similarly hand your ass to you in a hat not too long
ago?

Um...no, I don't think so. He has responded to several
contributors in a rather rude manner. It doesn't matter
that he thinks they are making things up.

Above, someone calls him on his rudeness. What does
he do? He responds with rudeness. What is he, 11?


I don't blame him for not candy coating the simple point he
keeps making--if it ain't in the books, you're just making it up!

I tend to stick with the books, too, but then, there are often
things implied that aren't in black and white. A good
story teller does that, you know.

Since this forum is here for HP fans to discuss their
ideas (most seem to call them "theories" without much
thought as to what that word really means), I think
Matt is way out of line to respond the way he does.


Matt doesn't think so.

I say again, if he doesn't want to read the "theories",
he should just go away, or I shall taunt him a
second time.


You lack the intellectual horse-power to taunt me effectively.

You've got a killfile, feel free to use it.

--
www.mattclara.com


.

Relevant Pages