Fawkes the ideal Horcux?



In CoS Fawkes is sent to help Harry in the chamber together with
Griffindor´s hat and sword. I think it is rather likely that Fawkes
was Gryffindors phoenix, too. He would make the ideal Horcrux because
he cannot be killed - he always returns! Or can they die? Where is
Fawkes now and how did Dumbledore get him? We know that V. had
Hufflepuff´s cup and Slytherin´s locket. That makes it likely that he
wanted two other "items" from Ravenclaw and Gryffindor. The question
is when V. might have got the possibility to make Fawkes a Horcrux.
Was that the reason why he wanted to become a teacher in Hogwarts? Or
did V. know about Horcruxes already and by killing Myrtle by the
basilisk he got the possibility to make a Horcrux? Was Fawkes DD´s
phoenix by that time already and did he live at Hogwarts then?

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Fawkes the ideal Horcux?
    ... He would make the ideal Horcrux because ... Fawkes now and how did Dumbledore get him? ... One of V's horcruxes helped Harry destroy another of V's Horcruxes and V's memory in the COS. ... You are not paying attention to Snape because the story is being told from a Gryffindor perspective and in a lot of cases from Harry's perspective in particular. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Fawkes the ideal Horcux?
    ... was Gryffindors phoenix, too. ... He would make the ideal Horcrux because ... Fawkes now and how did Dumbledore get him? ... wanted two other "items" from Ravenclaw and Gryffindor. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Fawkes the ideal Horcux?
    ... was Gryffindors phoenix, too. ... He would make the ideal Horcrux because ... Fawkes now and how did Dumbledore get him? ... Therefore, not an ideal horcrux. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Fawkes the ideal Horcux?
    ... was Gryffindors phoenix, too. ... He would make the ideal Horcrux because ... Fawkes now and how did Dumbledore get him? ... Was that the reason why he wanted to become a teacher in Hogwarts? ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Fawkes the ideal Horcux?
    ... was Gryffindors phoenix, too. ... He would make the ideal Horcrux because ... Fawkes now and how did Dumbledore get him? ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)