Re: Unanswered Questions
- From: Thom Madura <Thom-Madura@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Tue, 06 Mar 2007 13:02:25 GMT
On Mon, 05 Mar 2007 19:44:25 -0800, richard e white <chiphead@xxxxxxx>
That is one of the biggest hurtals for the snape is good people.
Snape never tells DD that peter was the spy. Acording to DD snape joined DD's
side long before V's fall. Though it is posable that snape doesn't know peter
was a DE until later.
The reason DD never learned that peter was the secret keeper? My bet is that he
didn't meat with peter dureing the week the charm was up. And peter faked his
own death just after. I think peter saw no one but black after V's fall. This
twin state makes it hard for any to know peter was up to something.
Only black knew and he said he went a little funny after peter got away. By the
time black was right in the head Crouch sr had already sent him off with out a
We know Voldemort never informed DE's of each other.
Where do we know this? When V used his mark to summon the DE"s - they came TOGETHER - how did they not know each other?
reason to believe Snape knew of Peter.
Since Snape was marked by V - and Peter was not - I agree
Seems people have this idea
Snape's the most trusted DE around. privy to all V's secrets. Is
seriously doubt he's well informed at any given time.
I am sure that no DE was truly trusted by V. Howver - when they got together - that means they all got some common information.
unnoticed until he told about the Partial Prophecy. Maybe he got
rewarded. But do you seriously think Voldemort would reward him by
sparing a mud blood he loved? A low level nothing boy who only did
one useful thing? At least Peter spied for a year. Then told the
I continue to believe that V considered that he had to eliminate the blood line that night to not only kill the "one with the power" - but to also prevent a future one from being born. I am sure he considered the Potter pure blood line to be the culprit against him - not Lily's muggle heritage.
Since I still believe that James and Harry are heirs to Gryffindor - something Lily could not be - V wanted to destroy that bloodline. Lily was no threat to V so he didn't care what happened to her - just make sure the Potter bloodline is gone. Lacking love - I am sure V never considered that Liily would commit suicide for her son.
- Prev by Date: Re: Unanswered Questions
- Next by Date: Re: Potter costumes
- Previous by thread: Re: Unanswered Questions
- Next by thread: Re: Unanswered Questions