Re: Secret Keeper


<ag30476@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1153585314.849310.266260@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

DaveD wrote:

[big snip]

Sorry for shouting but

MAGIC IN THE HP WORLD IS NOT CONSISTENT BECAUSE IT IS THE MAGICAL
TECHNOLOGY OF AN IMAGINARY WORLD.


Erm, might I suggest you may be taking this a bit too seriously?

Of course, the more consistent JKR's "rules" of magic are, the more
enjoyable are the books - random inconsistent magic would be boring and
annoying. Of course, there may be a few mistakes or inconsistencies here and
there, but it's fun playing with what we've been told so far to try and
explain situations or extrapolate from them and possibly work out a few
clues for book 7. I'm sorry if you don't enjoy that but I don't think that's
grounds for shouting etc.

Perhaps we should draw this thread to a close before a flamewar starts :)

DaveD



.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Japanese self study advice
    ... I think a number of people mentioned a number of good books, dictionaries, advice, etc. ... Do it in a relaxed, comfortable and focused, but most importantly, regular and consistent environment. ... Put together a list of vocab in alphabetical order so you can have a drill "game" where you proceed through the alphabet reminding yourself of each word one by one as you do otherwise mindless and mundane tasks; ... Listen to a phrase on talk-radio, or an overheard conversation at the bus-stop or online at the grocery store, and try to fashion it into a crude translation. ...
    (sci.lang.japan)
  • Re: Dates in the books (was: The Identity of R.A.B.--My Speculation)
    ... > support for in the books. ... > precise and detailed time-line for Tom Riddle's young years (saying ... > consistent one). ... minor errors and inconsistencies regarding dates. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Who is winning Pick-16 for UK649?
    ... jackpots on a consistent basis they would spend their time using their ... Serotic has not published any book recently but his old books are ... However you should be aware that the price of a 'Collectors Edition' is not ...
    (rec.gambling.lottery)
  • Re: Induction of statistical models
    ... This question reminds me of someone asking for good books on ... consistent with the data, pick the simplest one". ... Model Selection and Multi-Model Inference ... However, Bayesians disagree with Occam's razor, and with model ...
    (sci.stat.math)
  • Re: Aleem Darr does it Again
    ... I believe we need to start using more technology. ... >> more consistent. ... > Nah - it'll ruin the difference between good and great batsmen. ... It may encourage bowlers whose style of bowling favours LBWs and close ...
    (rec.sport.cricket)
Loading