Re: Why I think Harry is not a Horcrux

On 8 Apr 2006 06:46:55 -0700, "Jane Grey" <jane.grey@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
wrote:

Toon wrote:
On 7 Apr 2006 12:49:56 -0700, "Jane Grey" <jane.grey@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
wrote:

isn't this a big presumption on your part (that if harry was a horcrux
it'll take a lot of writing to incorporate)? seeing as, if harry is a
horcrux, you don't know what part it will play.

Um, a really, really big part.

it will be big in terms of shaping the plot but that doesn't mean that
a lot of writing is needed. harry could find out he's a horcrux in a
matter of a paragraph (maybe AD's bro alberforth tells him) and decide
he must sacrifice himself in a paragrah. then he uses this connection
to LV to locate the other horcruxes, this won't need to take more than
a paragraph for each horcrux. aaron was implying that harry can't be a
horcrux because if if harry was a horcrux, book7 would be too big -i'm
merely pointing out that that isn't necesarily the case because the
harry is a horcrux plot will be entwined with the expected plot (of
harry going to Bill's wedding, godrics hollow then tracking down and
destorying the remaining horcruxes before going after Nagini/Voldemort)
therefore will not necessarily add a great deal of additional chapters
in itself.

"Hmmm. Dd left me this packet in his will, entitled CPP. Wow, I'm a
horcrux, I can track the others now, and he wanted Snape to kill him.
Thank goodness for Convenient Plot Points."
.

Relevant Pages

  • DIVINATION TEST (REPOST)
    ... Answer whether the each of the following is a Horcrux. ... Harry, or his scar ... Fleur is a spy for Voldemort. ... Albus Dumbledore will return to life; ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Why Harry *isnt* a Horcrux
    ... Voldemort would have done the horcrux creating spell right after ... something in the books to contradict it. ... > in CoS AD tells harry that Voldemort ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Harry probably is a Horcrux, yknow!
    ... If Harry became the Horcrux by ... >>>accident, that's what accidentally creating a Horcrux means. ... slughorn said that killing rips the soul apart, ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Why Harry *isnt* a Horcrux
    ... > of course it is speculation, all theories, by nature, are. ... in CoS AD tells harry that Voldemort ... explanations that Harry is a Horcrux. ... That is the reason why I try to ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Why Harry *isnt* a Horcrux
    ... well of course it's not in the books that harry is a horcrux if JKR ... in CoS AD tells harry that Voldemort ... >Not sure where you got the idea that LV's soul was ripped after he killed ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)