Re: Snape's Vow (was: Half Blood Prince Major Letdown)
- From: Steven Sousa <ssousa@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Thu, 06 Apr 2006 15:40:01 -0400
eggplant wrote:
In fact, if whatever happened that night was NOT
part of DD's plan, then she has made DD into a fool
So you think it was part of Dumbledore's plan to let a band of Death
Eaters and a murderous werewolf who likes to attack kids break into a
castle full of children while he was away and unable to defend it.
Well..... we know with certainty that Dumbledore has made some blunders
in his life, some of them quite serious, but he's never done anything
that idiotic.
The wizarding world has a different view on risking people's lives than you or I. Exhibit A: The Tri-Wizard tourney. They risked four young wizards lives for a sport? Quiddich is also a pretty brutal game for school-age kids to play.
The Order got to Hogwarts pretty quickly, and DD knew that he was the real target of their mission, so student casualties seemed unlikely.
.
- References:
- Snape's Vow (was: Half Blood Prince Major Letdown)
- From: eggplant
- Snape's Vow (was: Half Blood Prince Major Letdown)
- Prev by Date: wombat ID code
- Next by Date: Re: why not release book 7 and film 5 at the same time?
- Previous by thread: Snape's Vow (was: Half Blood Prince Major Letdown)
- Next by thread: Re: Snape's Vow (was: Half Blood Prince Major Letdown)
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|
