Re: Why I think Harry is not a Horcrux

Jane Grey wrote:

Toon wrote:

or maybe the Soul Bit got trapped in a scab,
which promptly fell off, leaving a scar. But the Soul Bit immediately
began leaking powers into Harry. And then got interrupted when the
scab fell off.

only scabs don't occur immeditaly after an injury do they? they occur
once the healing process has started if i remember correctly... besides
i don't think harry's Scar is the same sort of scar you or I might get
when we scrape our knees...

When we first see Harry (book 1 chapter 1) he is described as having

"a curiously shaped cut, like a bolt of lightning"

though Dumbledore talks about the boy having that scar forever, he must
be referring to a scar which will soon be forming, not already there.


Blon Fel Fotch Passameer-Day Slitheen

--
Free Margaret Blaine now!

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Godrics Hollow and the missing day - LONG spoilers
    ... as evidence that the muggles could get to the nearly destroyed house. ... spot after recovering LV's wand...but then what does Harry get to see ... It's Dumbledore who calls it a scar ... If V planned to possess Harry, ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Harry Potters Scar
    ... After Voldemort tries to AK him, Harry ... :>> the only people who would know about it would be Hagrid, Dumbeldore, ... :>> Dumbeldore would not likely tell anyone about the scar, ... :>> time Harry comes to Hogwarts? ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: POOR HARRY!!!!!!!!!!!
    ... >> I think in the unlikely event of Harry's scar being a Horcrux then it ... >> when death intervened perhaps as you say he has left a memory for Harry ... >>> connection. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Harry Potters Scar
    ... If they were trying to hide him, Hagrid, Minerva and Dumbeldore would not likely tell anyone about the scar, as its quite recognizable, the Dursleys sure as hell wouldn't be talking to anyone magical about it. ... So for me, the quesiton is, how does everyone and their owl know about the scar by the time Harry comes to Hogwarts? ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Harry Potters Scar
    ... If they were trying to hide him, Hagrid, Minerva and Dumbeldore would not likely tell anyone about the scar, as its quite recognizable, the Dursleys sure as hell wouldn't be talking to anyone magical about it. ... So for me, the quesiton is, how does everyone and their owl know about the scar by the time Harry comes to Hogwarts? ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)