Re: Ending of series - clue from book1
- From: "BaJoRi" <baronjosefr@xxxxxxx>
- Date: Fri, 31 Mar 2006 14:45:37 GMT
"IMS" <iscott@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:ph7q22939u15fbbog8ga577nobuoecqof7@xxxxxxxxxx
On 31 Mar 2006 01:16:26 -0800, "Dumbledore's Man" <cspirit@xxxxxxxxx>
wrote:
Hi all,
during a recent re-read of Sorcerer's Stone, my attention was drawn to
a detail that may as well answer one important question - will harry
survive post book7?
I say NO. Atleast that's what is written in the stars.
Yes, i am speaking about Harry's visit to Forbidden forest in book1 and
his meeting with the centaurs. When Bane and Ronan spot Firenze
carrying Harry on his back, they say something like : 'We have resolved
not to set ourselves against what the heavens are foretelling.' And
what exactly had Firenze done before meeting bane and ronan? He had
SAVED HARRY'S LIFE from Voldemort. Clearly, the centaurs have read in
stars that Harry is going to be killed by voldemort and firenze has
stopped this from happening.
Actually, the comment is used later as the reason the other centaurs ban
Firenze from the herd -- because Firenze decides to actually 'do fortune
telling' at Hogwarts. The comment doesn't have anything to do with
Harry.
No, I think he is on to something with that, and that the centaurs may very
well have seen maybe not Harry's death but V's triumph, or the triumph of
dark forces. And that instance in the first book may very well have been an
indicator of the fore-seeing of Harry's death, which Firenze interupted,
allowing Harry to go on and do other things to defeat the Dark.
The biggest questions is this: How does Grindewald factor in to everything.
I am relatively certain that we will find it is Grindewald that taught
Riddle how to make horcruxes, but I believe there is much more to it than
that.
Firenze saved Harry's life. Could be Firenze knew Harry's parrents, or
respected Harry as the 'boy who lived,' or simply valued life and didn't
want Harry dead if he could help it.
I know many of you will now think of something else- the interesting
interpretation of Prophecy by Dumbledore in book6. He says that it is
our choice to make a prophecy come true.
I don't.
That means, Harry can still set himself against the future in which he
is dead. But going by what stars say, He'll die.
No. The stars don't have anything to do with it. The book is about
love. Something Harry has laods of, and V has none of. It's going to
be the crux of the final battle. Harry will live.
--------------
You only live once, but if you do it right, once is enough.
--Mae West
--------------
.
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: Ending of series - clue from book1
- From: Here in Minnesota
- Re: Ending of series - clue from book1
- References:
- Ending of series - clue from book1
- From: Dumbledore's Man
- Ending of series - clue from book1
- Prev by Date: Re: JKR and Christian themes? (ON-TOPIC!)
- Next by Date: Re: Ending of series - clue from book1
- Previous by thread: Ending of series - clue from book1
- Next by thread: Re: Ending of series - clue from book1
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|
