Re: Why Was Pettigrew Sorted Into Gryffindor?

Kami wrote:
Jane Grey wrote:
sjmcarter@xxxxxxxxx wrote:
According to the sorting hat, Gryffindor house is for those who'se most
prominent quality is bravery, yet nothing about Peter Pettigrew suggest
a brave characetr. If anything, his sycophantic, self-serving nature
seems to make him a prime candidate for Slytherin. Why was he sorted
into Gryffindor?

I used to wonder this as well until I came up with an idea that
satisified me, see what you think of it:

Peter sits on the stool and nervously puts the sorting hat on. The Hats
finds a mind that is not particularly clever, ambitious, hard-working,
loyal or brave. Where to put this one? well he will do well if he had
friends who were brave and chivalrous so they would look out for him.
better be Gryffindor!

Jane, I like your idea, except I think that students are sorted by the
traits they possess rather than where they would do well. While it is
true enough that Peter doesn't strike me as the type that possesses any
of those qualities either, I do recall something from PS/SS that makes
me think that Peter would have been sorted into Hufflepuff if he wasn't
set to do something brave (and in the arena of redeeming) in Book 7. It
is mentioned, before the Sorting Hat was used to sort students, when
the founders did it themselves that Slytherin, Gryffindor, and
Ravenclaw took the ones that exemplified their own favored qualities,
but Hufflepuff said that she'd take the rest. So, if Peter lacked the
other qualities, he wouldn't necessarily need to be hardworking to be
sorted to Hufflepuff.

hmmm, good point! damn it, now i'm like why oh why oh Why Was Pettigrew
Sorted Into Gryffindor?!!

Therefore, I'm expecting that he'll do something
brave to justify his being sorted into Gryffindor.

or JKR put him there for plot purposes.

And for the record, I don't think that his going to LV, or the
sacrificing of is finger and hand were acts of bravery. I consider them
acts of a desperation from a coward, attempting to please those (LV &
DE) who are bigger, stronger, and more talented and can protect him.

yeah i'm inclined to agree

--
Jane Grey

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Why Was Pettigrew Sorted Into Gryffindor?
    ... a brave characetr. ... Peter sits on the stool and nervously puts the sorting hat on. ... better be Gryffindor! ... Ravenclaw took the ones that exemplified their own favored qualities, ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Snape = Gryffindor
    ... He is hardly 'noble, chivalrous and/or brave. ...  We know very little about Peter, ...  I can't imagine werewolf sympathizers ... Neville may not have had the opportunity to "turn" into a Pettigrew, ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: Snape = Gryffindor
    ... He is hardly 'noble, chivalrous and/or brave. ...  We know very little about Peter, and most of that is second ...  I can't imagine werewolf sympathizers get ... brave with the help of loyal friends, ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)
  • Re: New Chief Scout
    ... asking about the qualities you think the next Chief Scout should ... Peter Duncan's term is up in 2009, so who or what kind of person do you ... Eddie Langdown ...
    (uk.rec.scouting)
  • Re: Peter won baby!
    ... truckload more clean shots than Peter. ... Toney was brave and game, ...
    (rec.sport.boxing)