Re: Anyone care to argue Snapes guilt or innocence?

Green-Eyed Chris wrote:
In article <43f304cf$0$29115$5fc30a8@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>, "Silvia"
<ludiana@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:


"Green-Eyed Chris" <cwlNOSPAM@xxxxxxxxxx> ha scritto nel messaggio
news:cwlNOSPAM-1402061343190001@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
<snip>

Going a little bit into fan-fic mode, I could also envision Snape having
been orphaned (like LV) and taken in by the Evans family until reaching
legal wizarding age. Perhaps Snape's mother was simply under muggle
interrogation for a few months. It would help explain his respect for Lily
and protection of Harry. His hatred for James would have been increased by
the stupid decision to make Peter Pettigrew the Potter's secret keeper.
--
Chris

No respect for Lily: in "Snape's worst memory", OotP, he offends her because
of her blood, no matter she had defended him against James...


The short response to that is that he openly called her a "filthy little
Mudblood" to strengthen his candidacy for the Death Eaters. Lily
understood.

I argued the point that Lily was probably the only true friend Snape ever
had 4 months ago in my thread "Snape¹s Overlooked Memory".


You call that "a little bit into fan-fic mode" with a straight face? Wow.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: English usage
    ... Is the sentence above grammatically correct? ... As her mother, I feel indescribable joy at ... ... Then there's Bobby Burns' "my luv's like a red red rose," or, if you have an alcoholic mistress, "my luv's nose is like a red red rose," etc. ... To snip or not to snip: ...
    (alt.usage.english)
  • Re: I have...
    ... You really do have a thing for Jewish chicks, ... idea that's why my dad married her - he likes his food, and his mother ...
    (uk.people.support.depression)
  • Re: I found a letter from my Grandfather to my Mother
    ... [snip for brevity] ... of Holland, and now they are gone, I can't ask about it any more. ... a snapshot of his life during which time he was dating my mother. ...
    (rec.woodworking)
  • Re: Broadband for Silver Surfers - paging the experts
    ... My mother in law has developed an interest in the family tree and so on ...
    (uk.rec.motorcycles)
  • Re: "a liberated Europe" - why?
    ... hideous wallpaper, and contrived to tip myself off a small stool while ... not even reaching out dangerously. ...
    (alt.usage.english)