Re: CONFUSED

From: dicconf@xxxxxxxxx (Richard Eney)
Date: Fri, 10 Feb 2006 05:26:15 -0000

In article <-vSdnUV5IauVRXbenZ2dnUVZ_smdnZ2d@xxxxxxxxxxx>,
Kasey Ignarski <kaseyi@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
<snip>

Actually....in the book...on page 646 of the Scholastic Paperback
version,...

"You stand, Harry Potter, upon the remains of my late father." he hissed
softly. "A Muggle and a fool...very like your dear mother."

So in the book, V calls Lily a Muggle.

Not really. V says his late father was a muggle and a fool... then
he compares his father to Harry's mother and says they are very like
each other. He does not say they are identical, only that they are
similar, and the word muggle only refers to V's father.

=Tamar
.

References:
- CONFUSED
  - From: totoole67@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Re: CONFUSED
  - From: Weird Beard
- Re: CONFUSED
  - From: Kasey Ignarski

Prev by Date: Re: Character Names
Next by Date: Re: Character Names
Previous by thread: Re: CONFUSED
Next by thread: Re: CONFUSED
Index(es):
- Date
- Thread

Relevant Pages

Relations
... including what a appears to be an abusive Muggle father. ... We have also seen a very young Snape trying to ride a bucking ... Snape's father and both of Lily's parents were Muggles. ... if both Snape and Lily _shared a pair of Muggle grandparents_? ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter)
Re: Relations
... >including what a appears to be an abusive Muggle father. ... >that this may actually be a _pleasant_ memory for Snape, ... >if both Snape and Lily _shared a pair of Muggle grandparents_? ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter)
Re: Half Blood Prince Question, spoilers
... I can't recall the details of the domestic abuse memory ... I'm certain it was our first indication that his father was a Muggle. ... that memory of apparent domestic abuse seems to run counter ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter)
Re: JKR on Father hood (was: Snape for a Father?)
... >> another male relative (his father was a Muggle, ... >> that the man Harry saw was wearing Muggle clothing). ... and Crouch Jr. ... >So far we have exactly one good apple from a bad family, ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter)
Re: Dumbledore asked Snape to kill him
... Riddle's mother, Dean Thomas' father, Seamus's mother.... ... If one of his parents is a wizard, I'd say his father: ... Well I seem to recall reading that Ted was a muggle or muggle born in one of ...
(alt.fan.harry-potter)