Re: Why Harry *isn't* a Horcrux

Randy wrote:
> I suppose anything is possible. This is fiction. Remember, I only said I
> don't "believe" and I stated the reasons why. I'm no authority. JKR has
> been purposefully vague. Its probably one reason she's sold so many novels
> and why people are so interested in this story. Some people here seem to
> enjoy fan fiction more than the novels. It wasn't long ago that I read in
> this group how a fan was so enraged at JKR for debunking on her website the
> theory that Aunt Petunia has magical ability. How dare she do this?
> Because, its her story! She'll take it where she wants to go regardless
> what any of us think. Your theories are just as valid as mine. But, FWIW,
> I still don't believe Harry is a Horcrux.

Fair enough, I just wanted people to see that canonically the
possibility exists that harry is a horcrux and therefore it's just a
question of whether JKR had planned it that way all along.

--
Jane Grey

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Cyrillic alphabet on RISC OS
    ... it is not fact and fiction. ... > reasons for Christian belief in the bible. ... > I suggest that by not reading it you have done yourself a disservice - ... long to download here) is hardly going to be a measured, ...
    (comp.sys.acorn.misc)
  • Re: Outcasts - good stuff
    ... They are adopting a common strategy or series that fail, ... hermeneutic mode" when writing about the detective fiction genre). ... for me during the first three episodes, and I just got bored in the ... for reasons which are probably unrelated to this. ...
    (uk.media.tv.misc)
  • Re: Synthetic Telepathy, NDEs, and Psychotronics.
    ... :>: reasons for switching around my display name frequently ... Androcles, you then imply that spies and actors are also deranged then, ... Androcles, at this stage, it indeed is all a fiction. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Synthetic Telepathy, NDEs, and Psychotronics.
    ... :>: reasons for switching around my display name frequently ... Androcles, you then imply that spies and actors are also deranged then, ... Androcles, at this stage, it indeed is all a fiction. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: 21 July
    ... the reasons? ... JKR says the later date was to allow more through editing. ... good positioning as well. ...
    (alt.fan.harry-potter)